The central midfield looked disastrous from the off, I agree, but not one albion player in that first half turned up. Villa certainly played well - they had a plan to neutralise us and we had no answer. They looked very strong going forward and bossed the midfield.
And, no, I wasn‘t there...
That was the issue. If the defender hadn’t got a touch, and it comes clean off Pedro, then it is offside.
I think we were given the benefit of the doubt.
This debacle is not Hinshelwood’s fault but he doesn’t want to collect the ball from the defenders in tight areas.
You can say “he’s only 18, have to start somewhere, don’t be nasty etc” if you like, but it doesn’t change the fact it is one of the reasons we are not as effective as normal.