I understand your arguments but to me they are analogous to 'VAR doesn't work' (also true to an externt). Best to revise and upgrade, not bin, shirley?
With sensible people like the Germans maybe PR is good. Not sure it fits in with the 'taking back control' mentality here. And, although I...
Yes, you're right. But many (including me) feel that we should be able to vote directly for a person. The 'fairest' system for the PR supporters is a national list. If you do it locally then it is effective local FPTP, or a local mess with maybe 3 elected per constitiency. As for a national...
How do you elect a PR government? How do you elect any government with no party politics involved? Unless there are parties no constituency or individual can 'elect' a government, only an MP. In a party-free candidate system nobody would have any idea what the government would eventually look...
Or they could simply say '**** them. I'm going to do what I think is right, come what may, or my name isn't Jeremy Corbyn'.
Politics is the art of the possible.