Shaw was great for England in the Euros and has regressed (again). He's a real up and down player.
McTominay is a Pound Shop Roy Keane and wouldn't have been fit to lace the boots of the 1990s squad.
No, genuinely he wouldn't.
Not a team player, doesn't press or track back and right at the end of his career. He's stuck at United because no one else wants him.
Goals are ok but not if you're leaking them at the other end at a rate of knots and losing to "teams like Brighton".