So, in your understanding, if you took a big swing at someone, but missed, that would be ok... You've said intent isn't mentioned, so the lack of contact would mean no offence!!!
Sorry, there is no way that Ali J’s offence was a red... Walker’s reaction equally did not justify a yellow. He stood over AJ saying something, which I guess wasn’t pleasant by AJ’s expression. I would never encourage an Albion player to get an opponent sent off, but AJ’s lack of reaction to...
Oh, that's ok then... In which case why did he get s yellow card? It was a terrible decision, City knew it too as Walker didn't come out for second half...