As I understand it, your kids can come to all the daytime kick-offs, your friends can upgrade for 6 out of 8 evening matches, but because it's not 8 out of 8 you are stopping supporting the club?
I think the timing of the decision is poor by the club, but the decision itself seems proportionate...
So therefore the current policy is more flexible than the old one. He does seem to want to have his cake and eat it though.
I don't always agree with the club when it comes to ticket policy and pricing, but on this issue they seem to be fair.
The OP also said that he has had a ST for himself...