Everyone has the right to score as they see fit, and these ratings will always be subjective, but THAT is INSANE. Just read what you've written! 'Should have had a hat-trick'. 'Finishing really lets him down'. Score: 7.5!?
What would you have given him if he'd tucked a couple away? 15?
As I've commented elsewhere, I'm impressed with his movement and general play, but his finishing is sadly lacking.
From the BBC live text:
6:50 Attempt saved. Sam Baldock (Brighton and Hove Albion) right footed shot from the right side of the box is saved in the top centre of the goal...