I wouldnt be reporting on Greer unless workjng for a lower league club than Brighton so it would be much the same as I did when reporting on Greg Fee, early 90s for BL. I said that he was competent at that level so would obviously cope with lower grade but no better than we had at the time...
I dont think there is much difference certainly not sufficient to warrant a probable signing on fee plus higher wages. It is the done thing on here to slate Greer who is still considered good enough for Scotland despite the constant criticism shown here.
As you say IF Dunk was to leave the situation changes but at the moment Greer is as good as McShane would be for us. If we bring in a CB I would hope it would be one a lot quicker than we have and also McShane. I have heard good reports of the ex Arsenal lad in the DS for the future, is it...
I do not see McShane as the answer to any problems I would sooner we concentrate defensively on left back possibly a quicker right back and lastly a CB. Many more positions to be filled before CB.