I saw the replay on the press screen on that incident, the defender 100% won the ball and it would have been harsh to give a second yellow. My first instinct was sending off though.
Pushing a forward in the back in the box is a penalty, I don't see how anyone can dispute it or say it's soft, even if it was Barnes being pushed and you don't like him :smile:
Absolutely nailed on penalty as was the push on Upson