I think this is probably true but I still don't see how exactly that the Time War NotDoctor carrying out what needed to be done fits in with (particularly) Ten never shutting up about how he killed all the Time Lords, Daleks etc etc. Would seem to be identifying the acts with The Doctor rather...
I'm still holding on to the Valeyard business (mostly so that I can claim to be the first person on the thread to have mentioned it if it's true :D :D) but it's looking less and less likely I reckon. Liked the one on the link from @Acker79 about it being the original Doctor though.
Agree, the stories so far have been very weak and the acting not much better - I believe Matt Smith may be leaving soon but I think it's going to tak egetting rid of Stephan Moffatt and his 'back to the 70's' vibe to really pull the show around.
It was kind of weird - as 11 said he JH didn't act in The Doctor's name is the 50th anniversary episode (which is next) going to be in an alternate timeline?