Just because it was on target it doesn't mean it was a good penalty.
Not exactly. Obviously he scored his but they were both poor.
I maintain that Young's was closer to being a good penalty.
It's irrelevant that Cole's was on target, it was a poor penalty and saved. They were both poor penalties but in my opinion a penalty where you stop in the run up, don't get much power and don't put it near the corner is as bad as a penalty that hits the bar. If the Keeper goes the wrong way...
It's especially annoying that Cole missed as he scored an excellent penalty in the Champions League final.
I actually think Cole's penalty was worse than Young's. If Young's was a few inches lower it would have been brilliant whereas Cole's was very savable.