I feel you may be undermining value of the input from the others, what has Waters done of note since the break up? Gilmour's lyrics are a bit lightweight I accept and can't compare to the stuff Waters wrote but his guitar playing is quite brilliant and they did go on to make a couple of half...
I actually only listen to the track Atom Heart Mother tbh, and you're right the band weren't that keen on it anyway. I think watching sunsets in sunny climes whe I was young with AHM mother playing in the background may have influenced my love of the track somewhat. The Wall was Roger Waters...
I'm with you 100%. Comfortably Numb apart it does nothing for me. I'd stick Dark Side, Wish You Were Here, Atom Heart Mother and Meddle way in front of the Wall personally