[Albion] The third goal was offside?

[Nobby Cybergoat]

Goals change games

 

[Uh_huh_him]

Goals change games

Only if the conceding team are capable of scoring.

 

[Thunder Bolt]

It was offside.

But it’s irrelevant given we conceded three utterly terrible non-offside ones. That’s more worrying.

Focusing on the third goal is pathetic though.

The first goal was offside too. The linesman forgot his briefing and raised his flag. The tv didn’t show a decent angle in the replays.

 

[portlock seagull]

The bad loser thread.

Yep. But only because it was off side

 

[Justice]

Why concentrate on the offside did you see the state of the keeper

 

[Thunder Bolt]

The bad loser thread.

Very harsh. The pundits were also querying the decisions. Steve Sidwell pointed out a missing line.

 

[A1X]

The first goal was offside too. The linesman forgot his briefing and raised his flag. The tv didn’t show a decent angle in the replays.

It wasn’t offside. Lamptey clearly plays him on.

 

[Bodian]

The first goal was offside too. The linesman forgot his briefing and raised his flag. The tv didn’t show a decent angle in the replays.

I think we'll probably have to accept the first one. Even my home-made snip and sketch rule looks as though it was onside.

 

[LamieRobertson]

How is it pathetic? Its a goal that shouldn't have counted and its being rightly pointed out

I’d say it’s pathetic to say it’s pathetic…..we must obey those who know best and of course if you criticise those who are critical that’s criticised ……they are beyond criticism.

Ps looked offside to me and given little attention at the time by the two tnt commentators….but we must not be critical they know best

 

[Thunder Bolt]

It wasn’t offside. Lamptey clearly plays him on.

Sorry, not what I saw.

 

[Thunder Bolt]

I think we'll probably have to accept the first one. Even my home-made snip and sketch rule looks as though it was onside.

View attachment 178266

Where’s the ball?

 

[Silverhatch]

Miles off

As indeed were we.

 

[Bodian]

Where’s the ball?

Just leaving the foot of the guy on the right hand side of the semi-circle. The one who looks as though he is semaphoring.

 

[Machiavelli]

The first goal was offside too. The linesman forgot his briefing and raised his flag. The tv didn’t show a decent angle in the replays.

It really wasn't. Lamptey was playing him on and I suspect Dunk too.
The third was quite obviously off though and I don't see why it makes anyone a bad loser to make that claim

 

[Nobby Cybergoat]

Yes. First goal. Easily onside. A very well timed run.

Third goal. Obviously offside. Massive VAR cock up with procedures not followed. Again

 

[Thunder Bolt]

It really wasn't. Lamptey was playing him on and I suspect Dunk too.
The third was quite obviously off though and I don't see why it makes anyone a bad loser to make that claim

Look at post 28, although you can’t see where the ball is. Lamptey was facing the wrong way and Dunk is anticipating the ball coming in, so why was the Roma player already setting off? His fellow player was well offside, but I’m not counting him.

 

[Nobby Cybergoat]

I think we'll probably have to accept the first one. Even my home-made snip and sketch rule looks as though it was onside.

View attachment 178266

Not the point of the thread. But just look at the gaps in that picture.

Surely this one is down the positioning of Van Hecke, next to the centre circle. We're playing with effectively one centre half and two full backs.

Van Hecke, i'm guessing has been told to be like Stones and go into midfield sometimes, I doubt he would have done that off his own volition. His correct positioning should be 5 yards to the left of Dunk. Exactly where the ball goes.

If you look at the 4th goal, there's a similar story.

 

[Machiavelli]

Look at post 28, although you can’t see where the ball is. Lamptey was facing the wrong way and Dunk is anticipating the ball coming in, so why was the Roma player already setting off? His fellow player was well offside, but I’m not counting him.

Yes, I've seen that post. I've seen it on TV a fair few times too. Not sure how it's up for consideration.

 

[the wanderbus]

Bold to watch us defend for the rest of the game and think we wouldn’t have conceded at least once more.

We may well of done or , as we were having a good spell, we may have halved the defecit. Thanks to a terrible var decision we’ll never know.

 

[Thunder Bolt]

Yes, I've seen that post. I've seen it on TV a fair few times too. Not sure how it's up for consideration.

Nobody can tell me where the ball is and when it was kicked. It’s just a picture.