If the club has said goodbye come 1st September to a couple of those who have earned the right, would you consider that they've been mistreated by not being part of it?
Got something to say or just want fewer pesky ads? Join us... 😊
How many premiership players were in our starting line up today?
- Thread starter Binney on acid
- Start date
If the club has said goodbye come 1st September to a couple of those who have earned the right, would you consider that they've been mistreated by not being part of it?
carteater
Well-known member
This is going to be one long post:
Stockdale (if we can keep him), Duffy, Dunk, Goldson, Hunemeier, Pocognoli (hopefully we can sign him permanently (hopefully on a free)), Stephens (if we can keep him), Knockaert (if he can keep his composure and not sulk when we're not playing well and losing), March & Murray are all good enough imho.
Sidwell has experience, but I'm not sure if we're gonna keep him on.
Bruno would probably make the step up, but he will be 37 by the end of the season and surely eventually his age will catch up with him (I hope it doesn't, he's usually immense & he's a club legend now), I also don't think he'll be first choice.
Rosenior has some experience, but again I don't think he'll be first choice.
I'm not sure if we'll keep Bong.
I think Baldock will surprise his critics and be at least a good option off the bench, but I don't think we'll be playing 4-4-2 very often next season.
If Kayal is King Kayal of last season he'll be good enough, but from this season I'm not so sure (I know he's been injured so he may come back to his best after a pre season).
I hate to say it, but I'm not sure if Skalak, Hemed, Murphy, Towell, Lualua & Norwood will make the step up or not. I can see at least one of them leaving in the summer.
So, if we can keep Stockdale and Stephens and sign Pocognoli, I'd say we need to sign a fullback, a central midfielder, maybe even two CMs, one or two wingers, a CAM/number 10 as I think we'll be playing 4-5-1 although my hunch could be completely wrong, and one or two Strikers imho.
Stockdale (if we can keep him), Duffy, Dunk, Goldson, Hunemeier, Pocognoli (hopefully we can sign him permanently (hopefully on a free)), Stephens (if we can keep him), Knockaert (if he can keep his composure and not sulk when we're not playing well and losing), March & Murray are all good enough imho.
Sidwell has experience, but I'm not sure if we're gonna keep him on.
Bruno would probably make the step up, but he will be 37 by the end of the season and surely eventually his age will catch up with him (I hope it doesn't, he's usually immense & he's a club legend now), I also don't think he'll be first choice.
Rosenior has some experience, but again I don't think he'll be first choice.
I'm not sure if we'll keep Bong.
I think Baldock will surprise his critics and be at least a good option off the bench, but I don't think we'll be playing 4-4-2 very often next season.
If Kayal is King Kayal of last season he'll be good enough, but from this season I'm not so sure (I know he's been injured so he may come back to his best after a pre season).
I hate to say it, but I'm not sure if Skalak, Hemed, Murphy, Towell, Lualua & Norwood will make the step up or not. I can see at least one of them leaving in the summer.
So, if we can keep Stockdale and Stephens and sign Pocognoli, I'd say we need to sign a fullback, a central midfielder, maybe even two CMs, one or two wingers, a CAM/number 10 as I think we'll be playing 4-5-1 although my hunch could be completely wrong, and one or two Strikers imho.
I think very similarly and all those signings are necessary in the ideal world. Some might be on loan so won't break the bank. I would keep Murray as reserve target man striker.
carteater
Well-known member
I think all four of our CBs are good enough for the Premier League, so that's probably one area where we won't have to strengthen.
Of course I expect there will be 1-2 in defence, midfield and upfront (COG/Akpom), think we'll need to replace each of those as well as another keeper or two if Stockdale leaves.
CliveWalkerWingWizard
Well-known member
Based on what evidence?
I totally agree, but Goldson's recovery to full match fitness may takes ages. No risks taken.
my eyesight.
Bwian
Kiss my (_!_)
- Jul 14, 2003
- 15,898
So you were happy with that steaming turd served up today? With respect maybe you should go phuck your father you tw@at.
Bwian
Kiss my (_!_)
- Jul 14, 2003
- 15,898
Boo hoo
Badger Boy
Mr Badger
- Jan 28, 2016
- 3,655
Keep;
Stockdale, Bruno, Hünemeier, Dunk, Stephens, Kayal, Knockaert, Pocognoli, Murray, Goldson, March, Duffy, Rosenior, Walton.
Sent from my HTC One M8s using Tapatalk
Stockdale, Bruno, Hünemeier, Dunk, Stephens, Kayal, Knockaert, Pocognoli, Murray, Goldson, March, Duffy, Rosenior, Walton.
Sent from my HTC One M8s using Tapatalk
Blackadder
Brighton Bhuna Boy
Are you basing this on just today's performance? If so. even Knocky wouldn't make it. Stockdale and Stephens could leave as they are out of contract, which leaves... Dunk. OK (not sure why we bothered).
Watching on Sky today the commentator said that Brighton's average age was 29 the oldest in the division. But I suppose Sidwell, Murray & Bruno would account for most of that. The others are still to reach their peak.
When I saw the starting line up couldn't understand why March didn't start ahead of Skalak and why Bong was ahead of Rosenior & Pocognoli.
I think Bruno is good for one more season, so my calculation would be (assuming the club hang on to the better players)is to recruit a left back and a striker. Plus a holding midfielder & Right back for cover.
When I saw the starting line up couldn't understand why March didn't start ahead of Skalak and why Bong was ahead of Rosenior & Pocognoli.
I think Bruno is good for one more season, so my calculation would be (assuming the club hang on to the better players)is to recruit a left back and a striker. Plus a holding midfielder & Right back for cover.
Jim Van Winkle
Well-known member
Yep, that Ibrahimovic fella, he's a waste of space this year in the Premier League.
Sussex Nomad
Well-known member
I reckon we should transfer list the whole lot and start again, that'll do it.
HastingsSeagull
Well-known member
Those 5 are about right as starters though I like Poc if we can sign him.
We have plenty of excellent Prem bench players though and exceptional depth which is what got us up. But yeah we do need those 5-6 elite signings as any team would.
At least unlike most we shouldn't have to bring in a bunch of past it journeymen on huge contracts to fill out our squad as we are sorted behind the first 11
We have plenty of excellent Prem bench players though and exceptional depth which is what got us up. But yeah we do need those 5-6 elite signings as any team would.
At least unlike most we shouldn't have to bring in a bunch of past it journeymen on huge contracts to fill out our squad as we are sorted behind the first 11
What are you, 12? There's no need for abuse like that. People are quite rightly pissed off with that performance yesterday.
I see your location is Sheffield, maybe you need to move.
Bold Seagull
strong and stable with me, or...
8. Some had an off day. A couple of poor performances doesn't change what these players have achieved over 2 seasons.
- Jun 27, 2012
- 13,911
I'm guessing much of our squad will be there next season. Why wouldn't they be ? Virtually all of them are tied down to long contracts or probably soon will be (Stockdale, Stephens, Sidwell, Bong).
We'll get new "quality" players but not many and they will be replacing fringe or loan players in the squad. - COG, Lua Lua, Manu, Forren, Tomori, Ince, Towell, and Akpom
Assuming we can hang on to Knockaert, Dunk and Stephens that is.
We'll get new "quality" players but not many and they will be replacing fringe or loan players in the squad. - COG, Lua Lua, Manu, Forren, Tomori, Ince, Towell, and Akpom
Assuming we can hang on to Knockaert, Dunk and Stephens that is.