LamieRobertson
Not awoke
- Thread starter
- #21
Got something to say or just want fewer pesky ads? Join us... 😊
[Football] So Mike Dean...what did you think
- Thread starter LamieRobertson
- Start date
HAILSHAM SEAGULL
Well-known member
- Nov 9, 2009
- 10,347
Their goal was definately handball, followed by a very high foot, so it could have been stopped on either count.
The penalty was a pen but Muzza played for it and the defender got caught hook line and sinker.
From the upper East, right in line, Knocky's disallowed goal went straight in. We didnt think Muzza touched it so why was it disallowed for offside. It wasnt the The Complete and Utter Shysters fault though, he only followed the linos flag.
Be interesting to hear any views from people lower down and in line, did Muzza get a touch?
The penalty was a pen but Muzza played for it and the defender got caught hook line and sinker.
From the upper East, right in line, Knocky's disallowed goal went straight in. We didnt think Muzza touched it so why was it disallowed for offside. It wasnt the The Complete and Utter Shysters fault though, he only followed the linos flag.
Be interesting to hear any views from people lower down and in line, did Muzza get a touch?
Seriously? He was very clearly grinning when the loud, ironic cheers went up.
BensGrandad
New member
I thought that he generally was ok but no mention of our disallowed goal for offside too far away for me to comment.
- Jun 27, 2012
- 13,881
I think the Guardian's cheek has a large tongue inside it with that quote...
Overall, including his assistants, I thought it was a poor performance.
I haven't seen replays of the decisions, so maybe I'm wrong, I'm a lot further from the action than them, but it didn't look good.
It looked 100% offside.....and wouldn’t have been MDs decision anyway
Blues Rock DJ
New member
there's no 'S' in Abraham !!
BensGrandad
New member
People on the train were saying Murray definitely in an offside position but didnt get a touch so the old controversy returns.
High foot, but doesn't look like handball. See highlights, about 2m 15s:
https://highlightsfootball.com/video/brighton-hove-albion-vs-swansea-city-highlights/
Thunder Bolt
Silly old bat
The assistant lifted his flag immediately. I'm not sure whether Murray actually touched it.
Gazwag
5 millionth post poster
From the NS right in line with the flight of the ball IMO Murray did not touch the ball 100%, in fact it looked like his foot was no where near it.
GT49er
Well-known member
Beat me to it!
- Jun 27, 2012
- 13,881
If he was being a complete and utter then you could say he had a case for sending Murray off after that exuberant celebration post his 2nd goal given he was on a booking. (he didn't)
he also got the penalty right (blatant), the offside goal right (it was offside) and had a go at playing advantage a few times. The standing ovation was pantomime stuff. Don't blame him for taking it in good spirit. Serves us right. He loves all that shit.
he also got the penalty right (blatant), the offside goal right (it was offside) and had a go at playing advantage a few times. The standing ovation was pantomime stuff. Don't blame him for taking it in good spirit. Serves us right. He loves all that shit.
Gazwag
5 millionth post poster
There is if you have a ' between the M and S
- Jun 27, 2012
- 13,881
BensGrandad
New member
That was the view of many on the train to Lewes, that he didnt.
This.
Nobby's Betamax Video
New member
He awarded Swansea 17 free kicks to our 6. Some were ridiculously soft such as against Gross in the 1st half in the centre circle for what can only be described as "jumping up next to an opponent". On another occasion he ignored a blatant barge by Ayew in the 2nd half which sent our player (Bong?) flying, then within 5 minutes he ignored a similar barge on Knockhaert near the half way line.
I can accept a shit ref if they are consistently shit. But Dean was ridiculously inconsistent.
OK he awarded us a penalty. But he also missed / ignored the Abraham handball.
We won despite Dean.
I can accept a shit ref if they are consistently shit. But Dean was ridiculously inconsistent.
OK he awarded us a penalty. But he also missed / ignored the Abraham handball.
We won despite Dean.
Thunder Bolt
Silly old bat
My view from the north stand was a lot closer. but I couldn't be sure.