Got something to say or just want fewer pesky ads? Join us... 😊

Register Log in

Worst band that wew successful?



Is it PotG?

Is it PotG?

Thrifty non-licker
Feb 20, 2017
23,304
Sussex by the Sea
I have a library of c. 250,000 songs from Classical, Jazz, Pop, Northern Soul and Motown to Heavy Metal and Grunge. Whilst I respect the change that The Beatles started, their revolutionary new techniques and innovations, I basically do not find them easy listening at all, in fact quite the contrary.

I do not like their music, simple.
 




BRIGHT ON Q

BRIGHT ON Q

Well-known member
Jul 5, 2003
9,104
DavidinSouthampton said:
That's far too sensible. I was made to think when I was a student in the early 1970s, talking about music and I was being rude about the Wombles - well, who wouldn't. But one of my friends, who was not known for his over-sensitivity and himself was in to some fairly heavyweight jazz, said "Whatever we might say, they give a lot of people a lot of pleasure." That changed my thinking, and so now I would not say something is sh1t, I would just say I didn't like it, or them.

And I'm not U2's greatest fan, either.
Click to expand...

Saw them at Twickers on Sunday, absolutely phenomenal .
 


Kosh

Kosh

'The' Yaztromo
Jul 14, 2003
5,217
Yaztromo's Tower; the borders of Darkwood Forest
This thread is utterly brilliant.

Hmmmmmmmm

Who to anger first?!? Oooohhhh the agony of choice....

Hmmmmmm

Think popular artist, think big seller, think people who cellotape newspaper to their windows and listen solely to one artist/band who they love more than life itself:

Elvis Costello.
The Smiths.
The Manics.
Pulp.
Dodgy.
Anything John Peel rated.
David Bowie.


Runs away....


Heh heh furrrking brilliant.
 


Is it PotG?

Is it PotG?

Thrifty non-licker
Feb 20, 2017
23,304
Sussex by the Sea
Kosh said:
This thread is utterly brilliant.

Hmmmmmmmm

Who to anger first?!? Oooohhhh the agony of choice....

Hmmmmmm

Think popular artist, think big seller, think people who cellotape newspaper to their windows and listen solely to one artist/band who they love more than life itself.

Elvis Costello.
The Smiths.
The Manics.
Pulp.
Dodgy.
Anything John Peel rated.
David Bowie.


Runs away....


Heh heh furrrking brilliant.
Click to expand...

Well said indeed.
 






Garage_Doors

Garage_Doors

Originally the Swankers
Jun 28, 2008
11,789
Brighton
Aveacarlin' said:
You like your Pistols. Do you listen to Jonesy's Jukebox? Great listening especially the 'in studio' with Paul Cook. Well worth a visit.

Sent from my SM-G900F using Tapatalk
Click to expand...

Yes, always listen to Jonesy. Had Diggle as a guest last week and ripped the piss. A very good listen.
Johnny is my mate, invited me on his tour bus on his last visit :)
IMG_4622.JPG
 


Aveacarlin'

Aveacarlin'

New member
Jul 5, 2011
1,177
Garage_Doors said:
Yes, always listen to Jonesy. Had Diggle as a guest last week and ripped the piss. A very good listen.
Johnny is my mate, invited me on his tour bus on his last visit :)
View attachment 87114
Click to expand...
Quality! I've read John L's book 'No Dogs etc' some years back. Is his latest just an updated version? Also, I hear Lonely Boy is worth a read although I quite fancy the audio version as Jonsey can deliver a tale quite like no one else can!

Sent from my SM-G900F using Tapatalk
 


Garage_Doors

Garage_Doors

Originally the Swankers
Jun 28, 2008
11,789
Brighton
Aveacarlin' said:
Quality! I've read John L's book 'No Dogs etc' some years back. Is his latest just an updated version? Also, I hear Lonely Boy is worth a read although I quite fancy the audio version as Jonsey can deliver a tale quite like no one else can!

Sent from my SM-G900F using Tapatalk
Click to expand...

Same here, Jonesy has done a audio version but not been able to find it anywhere yet. Will be seeing the Professionals i a few weeks albeit without Steve as he didn't rejoin them when they reformed. But still a great band.
 








L

LU7 RED

Active member
Nov 5, 2010
562
Leighton Buzzard
Audax said:
Ed Sheeran shot himself in the foot with the back-to-back releases earlier this year from the new album. While each individual single has it's own style, they're still Ed's voice and hearing 3 of his tracks in my morning *and* evening commute is a bit too much (admittedly my commute is 2 hours, but still...). Space those releases out over a full year and I suspect folks would be lauding the stylistic changes in each track instead of bemoaning that we're constantly being bombarded with his tracks.

Anyway, my actual contribution to this thread:

Any poppy manufactured boy/girl band.

And along side them, the vast majority of X Factor etc winners (although thankfully most of those have turned out to be of only limited and short term success).
Click to expand...

I did try a few Ed Sheeran tracks on youtube, but hated them all, actually surprised me that they were that 'wet' and dreary (to my ears anyway). I think he's a cult to many tbh, it's all about his 'journey' against all odds and that stuff.

Mystified how his actual music can be that popular.
 






The_NitramJohn

The_NitramJohn

New member
Feb 18, 2012
41
Behind Enemy Lines said:
You may not like them but I'm sorry to say they were one of the worst bands which were successful is utter nonsense. One of THE hallmarks of a great band is when you hear them for the first time, it sounds nothing like you've heard before. The Smiths fall into that category. They had their own sound which was completely distinctive. No-one else sounded like them.
Only the really great acts have that. The Beatles, Bowie, The Pistols, Prince, Nirvana, Joy Division, Kraftwerk, AC/DC, they all had a sound which made you stop the first time you heard them. Not many have that. The Smiths did.
Click to expand...

Though not my cup of tea, I agree - you can't say they weren't an inspirational band with a unique sound.

My jibe was more at that section of their fans, who come across as genuinely shocked & upset that you don't hold Smiths/Morrisey in their same high esteem.

Maybe being unfair but, Havnt really experienced this, on the same level, with other bands fans.

not hard to work out my favourite band & genre - TBH couldn't care what others think , enjoying the music far too much [emoji41]

Yes, I'm a metalhead who enjoys playing Classical piano [emoji12]

I love music, not going to criticise bands for their music genres (only if the members/singers act like self obsessed dicks)
 


Psychobilly freakout

Psychobilly freakout

HellBilly
Feb 23, 2009
22,996
Brighton factually.....
DumLum said:
PLEASE explain why the Beatles were the worst band that were successful. Just to confirm: The most successful band ever were actually "The Worst"?
Can you also enlighten the rest of the world why they were rip off merchants? I understand some people think the Beatles were over rated but I think you may have gone a bit far with your look at me comment.
Click to expand...

I don't have to explain anything to anyone it is a message board asking for opinions and that is mine.

Ok I will, as I don't want to be rude.

All you have to do is look at everything they have ever done, and they copied from day one in the Cavern Club right through the mop heads, copied off other Liverpool bands at the time, and again through to the experimental phase that others were actually doing before them and just because they had more money and fame the media made them out to be at the cutting edge of everything...

It is not a look at me comment, I have said it before on here and I am not alone in my thinking.
 








Juan Albion

Juan Albion

Chicken Sniffer 3rd Class
Jul 9, 2003
31,370
Pontypool (Not THAT Pontypool, the one with the zo
Psychobilly freakout said:
All you have to do is look at everything they have ever done, and they copied from day one in the Cavern Club right through the mop heads, copied off other Liverpool bands at the time, and again through to the experimental phase that others were actually doing before them and just because they had more money and fame the media made them out to be at the cutting edge of everything...
Click to expand...

Basing a judgement that a band are "the worst" on anything other than what you hear is pretty stupid in my opinion.
 


The_NitramJohn

The_NitramJohn

New member
Feb 18, 2012
41
Psychobilly freakout said:
You do realise that rules out nearly every band and solo artist at one time or another in their career.
Click to expand...

Yes, aware of that LOL!

Including a lot of my music heroes [emoji41][emoji869]

Just, I'm happier to accept Gene Simmons being a dick, than Justin Beiber.

Biased, I know LOL!


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 




Psychobilly freakout

Psychobilly freakout

HellBilly
Feb 23, 2009
22,996
Brighton factually.....
Juan Albion said:
Basing a judgement that a band are "the worst" on anything other than what you hear is pretty stupid in my opinion.
Click to expand...

Eh...

Sorry that makes no sense to me, I am making that opinion precisely on what I hear...... pure bland music.

That is my opinion which is what this thread is about, sorry you don't like it, no need to get all defensive.

It don't make me right, I am well aware of that.

And people think Smiths fans get all up there own arse....

Meh
 
Last edited:


Juan Albion

Juan Albion

Chicken Sniffer 3rd Class
Jul 9, 2003
31,370
Pontypool (Not THAT Pontypool, the one with the zo
Psychobilly freakout said:
Eh...

Sorry that makes no sense to me, I am making that opinion precisely on what I hear...... pure bland music.

That is my opinion which is what this thread is about, sorry you don't like it, no need to get all defensive.

It don't make me right, I am well aware of that.

And people think Smiths fans get all up there own arse....

Meh
Click to expand...

I haven't expressed any opinion on the Beatles, I have expressed an opinion on your comments. You say NOW you made you judgement based on what you hear - pure bland music. But that's not what you wrote in the comment I was responding to in which you explained why they were the "worst band". You talked about them copying music and not being original. You talked about them being successful because of money and fame. That has NOTHING to do with what you've just written. You said nothing about the quality of the music in that post. All that matters is whether you enjoy something or not, and that's up to you. Whether they were "cutting edge" or copying others is pretty irrelevant if they did it better than others, but that is simply a question of taste.

Methinks you are the one getting all defensive and up your arse.
 


You must log in or register to reply here.

Share this page

Albion and Premier League latest from Sky Sports


Top
Link Here