[Food] Are gas barbecues cheating?

portlock seagull · Jul 22, 2018

Easy 10 said:
Do behave, Just because you're not MAN enough to handle an open flame, don't come on here giving it the biggun about your little kitchen hob.

I don't just BBQ either. I got me a SMOKER. Shove a rack of ribs in the main chamber, scatter some hickory smoked woodchips amongst the coals in the side one, and 4 hours later you've got yourself some prime flavoured pork, just falling off the bone. #redneck

[tweet]1020820467194744834[/tweet]

4hrs later (FOUR HOURS!), handy for weeknights eh? As for falling off the bone, that’s today’s pampered society right there! Get yourself a T bone and rip away the FLESH with your TEETH*, gnaw the vertebrae into a useful TOOL afterwards like a real MAN. Heck, sometimes I just eat my steaks plain RAW and ignore the SALAD

*don't forget to floss

btnbelle · Jul 22, 2018

Gas BBQ's just don't taste any different to oven cooked food that is eaten outside.

I also quite like sitting around waiting for the food to cook in its own time, its very relaxing. Although I tend not to be chef outside so perhaps thats what I like about it.

Is it PotG? · Jul 22, 2018

For a combination of safer cooking, ease of use, blending with the social side of BBQing and a place to rest your beer when two hands are needed, gas all day.

For the smokey, chargrilled effect over wet wood with a hint of pine, ponce about with one of those coal things.

swindonseagull · Jul 22, 2018

Depends on the cook !!

Green Gull · Jul 22, 2018

Just can't beat charcoal IMO. It's not just the taste that's better, I really enjoy the whole process of getting the thing prepared and lit properly then love watching it burn until it's 'cook' ready. It can be quite an art form getting it right if you're cooking things other than burgers & sausages. Think we're breaking the record for BBQ"s this summer in our household, on the 6th or 7th bag of charcoal already. Long may it continue.

I just think a gas BBQ as purely an outside cooker, convenient but not quite the same, is it?

Sent from my Pixel 2 using Tapatalk

Daddies_Sauce · Jul 22, 2018

Had a reasonably expensive charcoal BBQ it was rubbish cooking was poor, grill rusted and fell apart, replaced it with a gas BBQ that too was rubbish, now - Weber Master Touch BBQ (4+ years old now and not a spot of rust), Weber Chimney starter (no lighter fluid, chemicals or starter blocks required), rotisserie, charcoal, friends, drinks and sun, perfect.

LlcoolJ · Jul 22, 2018

Daddies_Sauce said:
Had a reasonably expensive charcoal BBQ it was rubbish cooking was poor, grill rusted and fell apart, replaced it with a gas BBQ that too was rubbish, now - Weber Master Touch BBQ (4+ years old now and not a spot of rust), Weber Chimney starter (no lighter fluid, chemicals or starter blocks required), rotisserie, charcoal, friends, drinks and sun, perfect.

Weber is the way to go.

Hillian1 · Jul 22, 2018

Dale Jasper said:
I’m nailing it meal after meal with my gas-powered barbecue, but feel strangely unfulfilled. Like I have given up on mastering real fire.
Are gas barbecues a sign of weakness?

Why not just ask your husband to do it If you can't?

DJ NOBO · Jul 22, 2018

Triggaaar said:
No.

Really? What sort of food are you nailing and how exactly is it being nailed, since you're not getting that smoky bbq flavour?

Posh Burgers and sausages mainly, but also fish and prawns.
You do get the smokey flavour to an extent as there’s charcoal, or an equivalent, in the bottom.

DJ NOBO · Jul 22, 2018

Hillian1 said:
Why not just ask your husband to do it If you can't?

Never said I couldn’t

Coldeanseagull · Jul 22, 2018

LlcoolJ said:
100% yes. It's just cooking, which is for girls. Whereas barbecuing is for MEN. You already knew this though or you wouldn't have had to ask the QUESTION.

This maybe so, but a womans work is never done..........that's why the blokes end up doing it

Superphil · Jul 22, 2018

Dale Jasper said:
I’m nailing it meal after meal with my gas-powered barbecue, but feel strangely unfulfilled. Like I have given up on mastering real fire.
Are gas barbecues a sign of weakness?

Not at all, it’s horses for courses and whatever suits what you want to cook. For convenience I use a Weber gas bbq, if I’m smoking I’ll use my Aquaforno or my Weber kettle. If it’s straight forward grilling then the Weber or my bog standard charcoal grill, if I’m feeling fancy I use my Tokat Mangali.

DavePage · Jul 22, 2018

At least with gas, whilst your reading the pages on Alireza Jahanbakhsh you could put the food on the back burner

Raleigh Chopper · Jul 22, 2018

Palace fans use one of the freestanding cookers that are in their front gardens, just run an extension lead out and the whole neighbourhood joins in.
Also able to keep the lager cold in the front garden fridge as well.
Other white goods are also readily available ( and sofas)

Creaky · Jul 22, 2018

It’s not ‘cheating’ but there again it’s not barbecuing either.

Triggaaar · Jul 22, 2018

Dale Jasper said:
Posh Burgers and sausages mainly, but also fish and prawns.

I'm stuck with a gas bbq - not through choice. I make nice smash burgers using a skillet, but I'm interested in these posh burgers you speak of (don't panic, I mean the recipe, rather than an invite).

You do get the smokey flavour to an extent as there’s charcoal, or an equivalent, in the bottom.

Eh? You what do you put and burn at the bottom? I'd be interested in smoke boxes (little boxes that you put wood inside), but I understand even they're not much use, as a gas bbq has too much airflow, whereas a proper bbq would leave the kettle full of smoke.

Hampster Gull · Jul 22, 2018

Herr Tubthumper · Jul 22, 2018

Dale Jasper said:
I’m nailing it meal after meal with my gas-powered barbecue, but feel strangely unfulfilled. Like I have given up on mastering real fire.
Are gas barbecues a sign of weakness?

My word. I bet you make salads for you BBQ events as well :facepalm:

Geestar · Jul 22, 2018

Gas is dangerous...

Sent from my TA-1020 using Tapatalk

Got something to say or just want fewer pesky ads? Join us... 😊

[Food] Are gas barbecues cheating?

Why? Why us?

New member

Thrifty non-licker

Well-known member

New member

Falmer WSL, not a JCL

Mama said knock you out.

( . ) ( . )

Well-known member

Well-known member

Opinionated

Dismember

Well-known member

New member

Well-known member

Well-known member

New member

Well-known member

New member

Share this page