Got something to say or just want fewer pesky ads? Join us... 😊

[Music] Allan Holdsworth, Greatest ever British guitar hero?





DavidinSouthampton

Well-known member
NSC Patreon
Jan 3, 2012
16,536
Doesn't the plaudit depend on the type of music played. Is John Williams a lesser talent because he plays classical music or Martin Taylor who is a jazzman?

John Williams is Australian.

having said that, I saw him in concert (solo) some 45 years ago and he was wonderful - certainly ranks in the top 3 of musical talents that I have ever seen in my life..... which I guess helps prove your point.
 


Superphil

Dismember
Jul 7, 2003
25,398
In a pile of football shirts
Big Jim Sullivan.

Performed on around 750 charting singles over his career, including 54 UK Number One hits.

Taught Ritchie Blackmore to play guitar.

Lived for many years in West Sussex till his untimely death in 2012.

His band backed Gene Vincent and Eddie Cochran on U.K. tour of 1960.

He, Blackmore and Pete Townsend convinced Jim Marshal to, and helped him develop, the now legendary guitar amplifiers.
 
Last edited:


Blues Rock DJ

New member
Apr 18, 2011
4,007
Dorset
Big Jim Sullivan.

Performed on around 750 charting singles over his career, including 54 UK Number One hits.

Taught Ritchie Blackmore to play guitar.

Lived for many years in West Sussex till his untimely death in 2012.

His band backed Gene Vincent and Eddie Cochran on U.K. tour of 1960.

He, Blackmore and Pete Townsend convinced Jim Marshal to, and helped him develop, the now legendary guitar amplifiers.

think things have moved on since the 60's........you'll be lauding Bert Weedon or Hank Marvin next.....
 


Superphil

Dismember
Jul 7, 2003
25,398
In a pile of football shirts
think things have moved on since the 60's........you'll be lauding Bert Weedon or Hank Marvin next.....

Thread title is Greatest EVER, hence I chose one of my favourites. And I think he did move on into the 70s and 80s as an immensely successful session guitarist, as well as producer and mentor to many other acts. Always modest and down to earth, played with Willie Austen around West Sussex for many years.
 
Last edited:






Icy Gull

Back on the rollercoaster
Jul 5, 2003
72,015
think things have moved on since the 60's........you'll be lauding Bert Weedon or Hank Marvin next.....

So modern guitarists are better than those from the sixties or seventies? Hmm not for me

I’ll have you know that Hank Marvin was Mark Knopfler’s inspiration, he even went for the trademark red guitar too. :smile:
 


Marxo

Well-known member
Aug 7, 2011
4,315
Ghent, Belgium
Allan Holdsworth great not greatest. One of the most respected among 'great' guitarists is Jeff Beck. My favourite is the late great Ollie Halsall.
 




Mick Green of Johnny Kidd and the Pirates. Huge influence on Wilko Johnson who I believe once said that he should have "Britain's no 1 Mick Green tribute act" on his CV.
 


The Sock of Poskett

The best is yet to come (spoiler alert)
Jun 12, 2009
2,802
Thread title is Greatest EVER, hence I chose one of my favourites. And I think he did move on into the 70s and 80s as an immensely successful session guitarist, as well as producer and mentor to many other acts. Always modest and down to earth, played with Willie Austen around West Sussex for many years.

I've got one of the albums he recorded with his band Tiger in the mid 70s - excellent it is too.
 








Superphil

Dismember
Jul 7, 2003
25,398
In a pile of football shirts
I've got one of the albums he recorded with his band Tiger in the mid 70s - excellent it is too.

This one? On my turntable this morning as it happens.

99f4f21841107c493f08bb27567688ff.jpg
 


GT49er

Well-known member
Feb 1, 2009
46,469
Gloucester
So modern guitarists are better than those from the sixties or seventies?

Of course they are. Many excellent (great if you prefer) guitarists in the 60s and 70s did wonderful things, very innovative things, and took electric guitar playing on to a different level. Today's best guitarists have absorbed and learned all the tricks and ideas from the 60s and 70s - and added more of their own. So, ergo, they've improved the standard of guitar playing so are (collectively) better.
A good analogy would be the Cruyff turn. When Cruyff launched it on the world stage in the 1970s the world stood back in amazement; now we've even got players playing for little old Brighton who can do it!
Oh, and as for the question of who is the greatest ever guitarist, the answer is no-one. There are, and have been, many great guitarists (including some that haven't even been mentioned on this thread yet) but they all have their different strengths and characteristics. Many greats, but not one greatest - saying 'XXX' is the greatest means nothing, except that 'XXX' is your favourite!
 




The Sock of Poskett

The best is yet to come (spoiler alert)
Jun 12, 2009
2,802






Icy Gull

Back on the rollercoaster
Jul 5, 2003
72,015
Of course they are. Many excellent (great if you prefer) guitarists in the 60s and 70s did wonderful things, very innovative things, and took electric guitar playing on to a different level. Today's best guitarists have absorbed and learned all the tricks and ideas from the 60s and 70s - and added more of their own. So, ergo, they've improved the standard of guitar playing so are (collectively) better.
A good analogy would be the Cruyff turn. When Cruyff launched it on the world stage in the 1970s the world stood back in amazement; now we've even got players playing for little old Brighton who can do it!
Oh, and as for the question of who is the greatest ever guitarist, the answer is no-one. There are, and have been, many great guitarists (including some that haven't even been mentioned on this thread yet) but they all have their different strengths and characteristics. Many greats, but not one greatest - saying 'XXX' is the greatest means nothing, except that 'XXX' is your favourite![/QUOTE

Well perhaps you can point me to modern guitarists who’s music I will enjoy as much as Jeff Beck, Carlos Santana, Neil Young and Peter Green...just for starters. I’m not interested is sound alikes but those who have a similar style but have improved on it, because I am going to be gobsmacked if you can.
 




GT49er

Well-known member
Feb 1, 2009
46,469
Gloucester
Well perhaps you can point me to modern guitarists who’s music I will enjoy as much as Jeff Beck, Carlos Santana, Neil Young and Peter Green...just for starters. I’m not interested is sound alikes but those who have a similar style but have improved on it, because I am going to be gobsmacked if you can.

My point is proved. You enjoy your favourites. As do I - Thompson, Townshend, Hendrix I strong contention for me, they're my favourites, or among them. What they did was wonderful - now there's guitarists everywhere who can play what they did, although to be fair, I've not heard many that xcan do a Thompson or a Townshend. Hendrix, Clapton, Santana, Neil Young, etc, no problem!
A 'sound alike', as you so dismissively describe them, if the are playing what the greats of the past are playing, then at this moment they are actually as good as they were then. The fact that many can 'do' more than one of the greats puts them a step upwards. Like you, my tastes are a bit stuck in time; I don't see (hear) the same excitement or innovation these days, but technically, as in all things, things have moved on. It that respect it doesn't matter whether or not you enjoy it.
You, like me, will continue to enjoy our favourites, hopefully for a long time! :thumbsup:

PS The Cruyff turn analogy is a good one. You can watch people do the Cruyff turn all over the place these days just as well as the master, maybe a bit quicker or slicker. But it doesn't take your breath away like Cruyff did when he did it.
 


Icy Gull

Back on the rollercoaster
Jul 5, 2003
72,015
My point is proved. You enjoy your favourites. As do I - Thompson, Townshend, Hendrix I strong contention for me, they're my favourites, or among them. What they did was wonderful - now there's guitarists everywhere who can play what they did, although to be fair, I've not heard many that xcan do a Thompson or a Townshend. Hendrix, Clapton, Santana, Neil Young, etc, no problem!
A 'sound alike', as you so dismissively describe them, if the are playing what the greats of the past are playing, then at this moment they are actually as good as they were then. The fact that many can 'do' more than one of the greats puts them a step upwards. Like you, my tastes are a bit stuck in time; I don't see (hear) the same excitement or innovation these days, but technically, as in all things, things have moved on. It that respect it doesn't matter whether or not you enjoy it.
You, like me, will continue to enjoy our favourites, hopefully for a long time! :thumbsup:

PS The Cruyff turn analogy is a good one. You can watch people do the Cruyff turn all over the place these days just as well as the master, maybe a bit quicker or slicker. But it doesn't take your breath away like Cruyff did when he did it.

I guess my point is that the guitarists I was alluding to played in bands where their style compliments the tracks that they are playing, so apart from being great guitar players the playing is crucial to the quality of the style of music being played. As an example Neil Young’s playing on live versions of Like a Hurricane makes a very good song excellent. So yes there may be guitarists who can play in the style of the old guys but are they able to compliment some great songs/instrumentals? I genuinely would like to hear their names and the bands they play in if so. I have heard some excellent guitar playing but I don’t seem to be hearing anything that hasn’t been done before and I can’t enthuse about the songs/tracks I am hearing.

Maybe [MENTION=5200]Buzzer[/MENTION] can help here, he has his finger on the pulse of modern music?
 



Paying the bills

Latest Discussions

Paying the bills

Paying the bills

Paying the bills

Albion and Premier League latest from Sky Sports


Top
Link Here