[Albion] Goldson or Duffy v Palace?

perseus · Apr 8, 2018

Uwe Hünemeier on the bench instead of Goldson

PS: it was very nearly an enforced absence for Duffy.

Cowfold Seagull · Apr 8, 2018

Bold Seagull said:
Was it a bad performance?

Was Duffy's error comparable to Propper and Izquierdo missing gilt edged chances to score a goal / win the game, or Dunk's free header 4 yards out?

I thought Duffy made a single terrible error in the game, but otherwise had a solid commanding performance at the back with Lewis. He made a mistake, we move on. I didn't see it as a bad performance for the other 90mins of the match.

Absolutely. :thumbsup:

Thunder Bolt · Apr 8, 2018

Cowfold Seagull said:
Why do we need to create uncertainty and change the team at all? Duffy made one, ONE, serious mistake against Huddersfield which led to their goal yesterday. Apart from that they offered very little.

To my mind it's entirely wrong for him to be made a scapegoat. The fact that we didn't pick up all three points, was more down to our strikers and missed opportunities of our own. Even with ten men we could, and perhaps should, have won the game in the final fifteen minutes.

Shane Duffy apologised to the fans on Twitter, using the Simpsons gif of disappearing into the hedge.
To a man, Brighton fans have backed him, not abusing him.
An Everton fan has even commented on the class of Brighton fans.
The love for Shane here from Brighton fans is class, if one of ours makes a mistake he gets dogs abuse

Tom Hark Preston Park · Apr 8, 2018

Mad Dog Duffy has to be shoe-in shirley? Tho we'd maybe benefit from Goldson not being Duffy and not heading every corner he comes up for a foot over the bar. Every. Damn. Corner. SAKE!

Cowfold Seagull · Apr 8, 2018

Thunder Bolt said:
Shane Duffy apologised to the fans on Twitter, using the Simpsons gif of disappearing into the hedge.
To a man, Brighton fans have backed him, not abusing him.
An Everton fan has even commented on the class of Brighton fans.
The love for Shane here from Brighton fans is class, if one of ours makes a mistake he gets dogs abuse

Brighton fans may well have backed him to a man on twitter, just such a shame that can't be said for some of those on NSC. :facepalm:

London Irish · Apr 8, 2018

Stupid poll as it won't even cross Hughton's mind for a mili-second

Mo Gosfield · Apr 8, 2018

Cowfold Seagull said:
Brighton fans may well have backed him to a man on twitter, just such a shame that can't be said for some of those on NSC.

We are all entitled to our opinion. This is not a collective love-in.
A lot of posters are stating that it is one error and one error only. I disagree. I have been concerned about his form in a number of recent games .He went to pieces yesterday and had already made errors before the critical one. His game didn't pick up and Dunk and others had to do a lot of covering for him. A lot of fans just see the thumping headers and roar approval, whilst failing to apply a critical eye to other areas of his game.

Wardy's twin · Apr 8, 2018

Mo Gosfield said:
Just my point.
The big thumped header 20-30 yards straight to the opposition serves no purpose other than to delay the opposition for about ten seconds. Where are the cushioned headers, the subtlety, the finesse? There is none. Its just basic hoofing except with the head.

Indeed he is a very different player to Dunk who gets the ball down when he can...

BensGrandad · Apr 8, 2018

Mo Gosfield said:
Just my point.
The big thumped header 20-30 yards straight to the opposition serves no purpose other than to delay the opposition for about ten seconds. Where are the cushioned headers, the subtlety, the finesse? There is none. Its just basic hoofing except with the head.

The one occasion that he had the time and space to hoof it down the line to Schelotto or March he chose not to and to hesitate and then make a back pass towards our goal rather than a solid punt to Ryan if that is what he wanted to do.

Hampster Gull · Apr 8, 2018

Duffy. He will have something to prove he will leap McShane like and sort this rivalry once and for all

GT49er · Apr 8, 2018

CH is known for bing a cautious manager, unwilling to take a risk - but maybe the biggest risk now is playing players who are mentally and emotionally drained from having performed right at the very limit all season. Duffy isn't the only one who looks mentally shagged out - so play Goldson for a couple of matches; fortunately we have depth to do this at CB - unfortunately we don't have much scope for relieving our equally shagged out CMs.
Only six matches left - here's hoping it's not six too many for some........................................

Pevenseagull · Apr 8, 2018

That UTTER HORROR of a ball aside he's done a ****ing job this season. .....keep, I can't believe that this is a question.

Pevenseagull · Apr 8, 2018

..........not that I don't rate Goldson.
.
.
.who is ****ing excellent

sussex_guy2k2 · Apr 9, 2018

Plooks said:
I don't think it will be a good thing for the players to know that if they make a genuine error they will be hauled out of the team. That kind of pressure will result in negative play for fear of making an error.

In the same way knowing that consistently poor play keeps you in the team, making you complacent, even though there are hungry players in the squad desperate for games?

Tokyohands · Apr 9, 2018

Duffy, he's been magnificent for us.

Dolph Ins · Apr 9, 2018

www.whoscored.com/Teams/211/Show/England-Brighton

whoscored has him as our best player this season!

nicko31 · Apr 9, 2018

Magic Sponge said:
Duffy. Not the right time to start messing around with the team set up.
All players can have an off day, hopefully he will learn from it and be stronger in the next game.

Agree, keep the faith in Shane. Generally had a great season

Farehamseagull · Apr 9, 2018

Duffy definitely.

After that mid season wobble he’s actually played really well recently. Yes bad mistake on Saturday but he’ll be desperate to put that right on Saturday.

papajaff · Apr 9, 2018

Dougie said:
Duffy .

**** me, you are one sad tosser

Da Man Clay · Apr 9, 2018

sussex_guy2k2 said:
In the same way knowing that consistently poor play keeps you in the team, making you complacent, even though there are hungry players in the squad desperate for games?

Which isn’t happening. He’s had one poor game. Consistently poor performance gets you out of the team - see March for proof of that.

Got something to say or just want fewer pesky ads? Join us... 😊

[Albion] Goldson or Duffy v Palace?

Duffy or Goldson next game?

Duffy

Goldson

Broad Blue & White stripe

Fan of the 17 bus

Silly old bat

Will Post For Cash

Fan of the 17 bus

Well-known member

Well-known member

Well-known member

New member

New member

Well-known member

Anti-greed coalition

Anti-greed coalition

Well-known member

Well-known member

Well-known member

Well-known member

Solly March Fan Club

Well-known member

T'Blades

Share this page