[Albion] Dunk V Murray............fight

Cowfold Seagull said:

If it's a case of just naming players who might win a fist fight, may I put forward Doug Rougvie and Mark McCammon? Two characters I wouldn't want to upset. Maybe Ian Baird too, as that Donny defender found out at the last ever game at the Goldstone.

Click to expand...

*Gullsworth* said:

Darren Moore....no powder puff himself.

Click to expand...

R. Slicker said:

Ooh, the self confessed Murray hater starts a thread expecting everyone to vote Dunky, unlucky mouldy.[emoji3]

.
Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk

Click to expand...

Mouldy Boots said:

Not at all Mr rslicker.

I just wondered who people would prefer to have if there was a choice?

I have never denied I prefer a quality home grown lad who we have seen grow in to a mature irreplaceable player to any that have been bought in.

I am hoping Dunky gets the publicity he deserves as Glenn's agent seems to be getting him all over the media, Dunky just keeps getting the job done.

Nice lad and I hope he can go on to play as many games with the stripes as Kerry did.

Click to expand...

Mouldy Boots said:

A football fight.

You can only have one in your team at a time, who would you have?


Dunky for me as he is class and a leader and our leader and could he possibly top Kerry Mayo 400+ appearances (please)

Click to expand...

Philzo-93 said:

I honestly read this like these two had a bust up in the tunnel after the game or something.

My heart sank!

Click to expand...

*Gullsworth* said:

But you would never credit Palace traitor Murray? Why would you put a defender v a forward when we have decent competition in the back line.....Duffy

Click to expand...

Mouldy Boots said:

The question was Dunk or Murray, quite simple mate, not sure what Duffy has to do with it

Click to expand...

*Gullsworth* said:

Not a lot but Duffy is more of a like for like comparison.

Click to expand...

Mouldy Boots said:

But that wasn't the question.

So who would you choose

Click to expand...

*Gullsworth* said:

Mmm.....it is a difficult one, a question with different answers. Murray v Dunk.....right now Murray, he is scoring the goals and his replacements are only/possibly/maybe good enough to one day be as good. With Dunk, he is having a great season but I believe his replacement Balogun is a capable player. Ask me this question at the end of the season and I would say Dunk even if Murray scores 20 this season.

Click to expand...

*Gullsworth* said:

Mmm.....it is a difficult one, a question with different answers. Murray v Dunk.....right now Murray, he is scoring the goals and his replacements are only/possibly/maybe good enough to one day be as good. With Dunk, he is having a great season but I believe his replacement Balogun is a capable player. Ask me this question at the end of the season and I would say Dunk even if Murray scores 20 this season.

Click to expand...

Cowfold Seagull said:

Sorry, just a teeny weeny point. Why would you choose Dunky even if Glenn bags us 20 goals for the season? Those 20 goals would almost certainly earn us Premier League survival for another season!

Plus of course Murray would be both more expensive, amd more difficult to replace, proven goalscorers at our level are as rare as hens teeth.

Click to expand...

*Gullsworth* said:

If you asked me the question now it would be Murray as he is scoring goals. At the end of the season I would be of the opinion even if Murray scores 20 this season he most probably will not next season while Dunk will probably be as dependable and our prize asset.

Click to expand...

seagurn said:

I will trump you all with Chris Hutchings .... when chelski came down got himself into bovver with sussex ob then to get outof it signed for us 2/3 weeks later ..... never liked him a snake imo

Click to expand...