[Cricket] Third Ashes Test - England v Australia - Edgbaston

The Wizard · Jul 31, 2015

MrShaun15 said:
Lyth has looked seriously average so far for our opener...

Average? That's being kind.

Sargey · Jul 31, 2015

If we want to **** it from the start, there is no better opener than Alex Hales in the country for that.....If you want to see off the new ball, go back to Michael Carberry or Nick Compton?

Unfortunately I really don'y think Adam Lyth has it but I think he will be in the team for the whole Ashes series

Uncle Buck · Jul 31, 2015

Sargey said:
If we want to **** it from the start, there is no better opener than Alex Hales in the country for that.....If you want to see off the new ball, go back to Michael Carberry or Nick Compton?

Unfortunately I really don'y think Adam Lyth has it but I think he will be in the team for the whole Ashes series

Watching Hales last night, he could not pick or play the fast bowls that Mills bowled (that were not wide or no balls). Not sure what the Aussie attack would do to him.

Simster · Jul 31, 2015

Uncle Buck said:
Watching Hales last night, he could not pick or play the fast bowls that Mills bowled (that were not wide or no balls). Not sure what the Aussie attack would do to him.

But he deserves a chance, given that he is the only true candidate who hasn't had one yet.

Titanic · Jul 31, 2015

Woooah, we're half way there.... smashing cut from Root :clap2:

63-2, 58 needed

nwgull · Jul 31, 2015

Bon Jovi time for only 2 wickets.

Uncle Buck · Jul 31, 2015

Simster said:
But he deserves a chance, given that he is the only true candidate who hasn't had one yet.

That is a statement that is hard to argue with, on the revolving opener door policy, that England currently employ.

Simster · Jul 31, 2015

Uncle Buck said:
That is a statement that is hard to argue with, on the revolving opener door policy, that England currently employ.

In fairness, it's not so much a policy as a necessity. The selectors need one opener (prefererably two) to stake a claim to open with Cook. So far, none of them have proved good enough. Lyth, Compton, Carberry - none of them are head and shoulders ahead of the others, all good county openers without the class to cope with high quality fast bowling from both ends.

Pavilionaire · Jul 31, 2015

Simster said:
But he deserves a chance, given that he is the only true candidate who hasn't had one yet.

I feel the same way about Hales opening a test for England the same way as I feel about Andy Burnham or Yvette Cooper becoming Labour leader - if they were all that they'd have got the gig by now.

Sargey · Jul 31, 2015

Uncle Buck said:
Watching Hales last night, he could not pick or play the fast bowls that Mills bowled (that were not wide or no balls). Not sure what the Aussie attack would do to him.

Thats a fair point but I think if England decide Lyth is not the man, Hales should get a shot!

hans kraay fan club · Jul 31, 2015

Simster said:
In fairness, it's not so much a policy as a necessity. The selectors need one opener (prefererably two) to stake a claim to open with Cook. So far, none of them have proved good enough. Lyth, Compton, Carberry - none of them are head and shoulders ahead of the others, all good county openers without the class to cope with high quality fast bowling from both ends.

and Robson.

Uncle Buck · Jul 31, 2015

Simster said:
In fairness, it's not so much a policy as a necessity. The selectors need one opener (prefererably two) to stake a claim to open with Cook. So far, none of them have proved good enough. Lyth, Compton, Carberry - none of them are head and shoulders ahead of the others, all good county openers without the class to cope with high quality fast bowling from both ends.

I do not disagree.

Compton probably had the temperament, but not the technique. The others were generally lacking on both fronts.

Thunder Bolt · Jul 31, 2015

[tweet]627111698319675392[/tweet]

Titanic · Jul 31, 2015

Drinks... England 67-2 (16 overs), Bell 38* Root 10*, 54 required to win

fleet · Jul 31, 2015

With 2 down I'm relaxed, but if Root had been caught just then it may have started to be a bit of stress

Titanic · Jul 31, 2015

England 74-2 (19 overs), Bell 44* Root 11*, 47 required to win... ticking along nicely

Man of Harveys · Jul 31, 2015

Boycott is in PRIME form on TMS. Telling off Bell for hitting out, slurring after lunch. Poor Jim Maxwell co-commentating sounds like the bloke in the pub who's been cornered by someone who's one over the eight. Mrs Boycott had better have his dinner ready on time later.

KZNSeagull · Jul 31, 2015

Man of Harveys said:
Boycott is in PRIME form on TMS. Telling off Bell for hitting out, slurring after lunch. Poor Jim Maxwell co-commentating sounds like the bloke in the pub who's been cornered by someone who's one over the eight. Mrs Boycott had better have his dinner ready on time later.

. Ooh he is going on - it's like listening to that annoying motorway traffic drone. I have no idea what the score is!

Badger · Jul 31, 2015

Two WIDES in a row :lolol:

pasty · Jul 31, 2015

2 consecutive wides from Starc. Crowd start "are you Johnson in disguise" :lolol:

Got something to say or just want fewer pesky ads? Join us... 😊

[Cricket] Third Ashes Test - England v Australia - Edgbaston

Well-known member

New member

Ghost Writer

"the man's an arse"

Super Moderator

Well-known member

Ghost Writer

"the man's an arse"

Well-known member

New member

The voice of reason.

Ghost Writer

Silly old bat

Super Moderator

Well-known member

Super Moderator

Well-known member

Well-known member

NOT the Honey Badger

A different kind of pasty

Share this page