Best Ref at the Amex this season.
Got something to say or just want fewer pesky ads? Join us... 😊
[Albion] Andy Madley today’s ref
- Thread starter LamieRobertson
- Start date
mune ni kamome
Well-known member
Funny though, the Everton fans didn’t think he was all that good
blue-shifted
Banned
Easy to big up a ref after you've won.
I don't remember a single instance of a football supporter, praising a ref after a defeat though.
The ref yesterday was magnificent. As was the Palace one!!
I don't remember a single instance of a football supporter, praising a ref after a defeat though.
The ref yesterday was magnificent. As was the Palace one!!
Sussex Nomad
Well-known member
So was he good for 58 minutes at 0-0?
This.
I also watch an insane amount of football and this particular ref has always seemed decent. Not the sort of narcissistic bollocks you get (got) with Clattenburg and the Shyster.
MrSnuggles
Well-known member
- Apr 29, 2016
- 529
The ref had a good game. Got the major decision right and didn't fall for Ricarlisons antics and played on
Super Steve Earle
Well-known member
I thought he was the best ref we have seen in the Premier League. Untainted by players reputations, made fair and reasonable decisions throughout that you couldn't argue with. He let Everton decide whether to put the ball out when Richarlison fell over his feet and, when they played on, allowed Solly to play on too. I think any other ref would have stopped play, but Madley was obviously happy he knew what Richarlison was up to. Incidently, I thought Solly had a superb match.
As for the ref/lino goal incident, I saw at the time that the lino raised his flag, then immediately put it down, more like a semaphore signal than flagging for offside. I think he immediately realised his error. Madley rightly checked with him, but it only took a matter of seconds to confirm the goal. Madley is welcome at The Amex anytime.
As for the ref/lino goal incident, I saw at the time that the lino raised his flag, then immediately put it down, more like a semaphore signal than flagging for offside. I think he immediately realised his error. Madley rightly checked with him, but it only took a matter of seconds to confirm the goal. Madley is welcome at The Amex anytime.
Justice
Dangerous Idiot
Kavanagh and his useless female Lino can do one. He used to be good now he has become another top 4 licker. Somehow spotted a Murray hand ball conveniently after Kane had a melt down. Think it was last seasons Leicester game Massy was making up throw in decisions as she went along to the bemusement of both sets of players.
- Oct 17, 2008
- 10,667
He’s my favourite ref ever...
Justice
Dangerous Idiot
just cost us 2 more points.
How?
Justice
Dangerous Idiot
Ball was over the line for their second
1) surely it’s down to the linesman?
2) it was not out of play. The entire ball was not over the line.
Arguable. Even from the slow mo in the other thread, you could easily argue there is a sliver of the ball still in play.
Justice
Dangerous Idiot
I did say his team Pascal was onside against Leicester mistake by the same Lino.
Justice
Dangerous Idiot
In live play looked more out than in. He’s a useless Lino.
Eh? It's either in play or not and it's not an easy decision to make even with slow mo and with a freeze frame. Anyone blaming the lino for that when it is clearly a debatable decision is a complete clown.
Read what it says under his username. He has one out of two correct.
I’m not sure it was. Maybe a ridiculously small margin kept it in. But he’d already fouled Bernardo by then anyway so shouldn’t have mattered. Shoving someone over with your arm is not ‘shoulder to shoulder’.