[TV] Dr Who

Kosh · Nov 19, 2018

Acker79 said:
http://sartorialgeek.com/political-awareness-doctor-who/

Okay... I'm unsure if you read my first post today herein, but I applaud the casting decision and believe the orientation of the doctor to be irrelevant as to whether the show is actually any good. As I say it's okay and, akin to Star Trek, I accept it's always been a forerunner with regard to subtle and non too subtle social commentary. Really its more about how less subtle the messages now are, for a show so wrapped up in how clever it is, why be so overtly obvious with your 'right on' political and social statements?!? It's sits uncomfortably alongside the oft overly and (blink and you'll miss it) clever science fiction bits. This is after all, a sci-fi show, not a vehicle to perpetuate an almost mythical view of our multi cultural society.

Nah; as I grow older an weary of agenda mongering... I guess I just find it boring and oh so predictable, something the more classic aspects of 'Who never were.

It's too homely and non diabolic... it's too safe, and even when it tries to 'shock' it still reeks of a dud Quantum Leap episode...

This is only my opinion, that's all.

Giraffe · Nov 25, 2018

Another very average episode tonight. 5/10 for the witch one.

Curious Orange · Nov 25, 2018

Junior Orange watched the end fron behind a cushion. They are doing something right!

Super Steve Earle · Nov 25, 2018

Still far to PC. This time the persecution of women as witches. Bloody tiresome - time for a proper sci-fi episode with no preaching please.

Algernon · Nov 25, 2018

Caught the last half of it.
The King's accent was terrible.
Sorry but I think she's a Doctor Who lite.

studio150 · Nov 25, 2018

Super Steve Earle said:
time for a proper sci-fi episode with no preaching please.

Fear its going to be a long long wait

Deadly Danson · Nov 25, 2018

Giraffe said:
Another very average episode tonight. 5/10 for the witch one.

Agree. With the exception of last week's bright and breezy story it's been such a mediocre season. Lots of clunky dialogue, too many companions, a not quite Doctory enough Doctor (nothing to do with Jodie being a female - imagine Michelle Gomez being given a go) and fairly stagnant direction and music. I so want the series to be great and am willing it on but boy it's hard work. All a far cry from the sparkling dialogue and excitement of the RTD era or early Matt Smith or the last 2 seasons of McCoy or early Tom Baker. I feel I'm only watching out of a sense of duty now.

Motogull · Nov 25, 2018

I'm a very occasional watcher.

She's really good in my opinion.

Harry Wilson's tackle · Nov 25, 2018

Will watch it later. I find her goofy gormless yorkshire vogue a bit tiresome, bit it is still magic. Anyone else got the poppy thing from a previous episode yet? That was pure class. They were just red flowers in a field........genius.

vegster · Nov 25, 2018

An ok episode tonight, King James was a bit camp and over the top though.

dejavuatbtn · Nov 25, 2018

vegster said:
An ok episode tonight, King James was a bit camp and over the top though.

I’d call it VERY camp. Bit weird he wanted to take his new friend back to London with him!?

vegster · Nov 25, 2018

dejavuatbtn said:
I’d call it VERY camp. Bit weird he wanted to take his new friend back to London with him!?

Yes, good spot, was King James planning to use his Royal pricker on him at some point ?

vegster · Nov 25, 2018

Anyway, moving swiftly on, any idea what the Dalek's are going to make of a female Doctor when they appear ? They will appear, I hope, as I'm rather fond of the old psychotic dustbins.

Acker79 · Dec 10, 2018

So, with a full season/series under their collect belt, what do we think?

I miss the "cleverness" of the overarching story, the interconnectedness of the episodes. When they're linked you feel like it's this big story, where even the poorer episodes have a pay off. What cost is there to missing any of the episodes of this season? If you can miss an episode and you don't miss anything, what value does that episode have? If the same can be said about every episode, what value does the show have? Where was the 'and this is why you're going to be desperate for the next season...' cliff hanger?

I also miss some of the humour.

I think Jodie grew into the role and/or I grew accustomed to her in the role (I get that sort of transition with most of the doctors when they're new - a sense they are trying to much to be the previous doctor, them and the writers taking their time to find the newest version's character, me changing my expectations and not judging them by the previous doctor etc).

I'm still struggling with Bradley Walsh - I catch bits of The Chase most days when I get in from work, so it's hard to buy into him as graham in the same way I buy into the other characters who I only see each Wednesday. Not sure there was much growth or depth in the two younger companions.

The effects are mostly good. Exposition seems over done at times. I got little fed up with the overuse of the 'twist' of 'those villainous aliens? actually sympathetic/good guys it's the humans that are evil!'

I'd probably put this season ahead of Capaldi's first - that run just didn't sit right with me, either, but not sure I would rank it higher than any of the other recent years' offerings.

Nottseagull · Dec 11, 2018

Bry Nylon said:
She couldn't park it.*

*just a joke

Excellent!
Although I was disappointed you felt the need to add the asterisk for the benefit of the PC brigade.
How do you register a thumbs-up on Tapatalk?

Sent from my PRA-LX1 using Tapatalk

Nottseagull · Dec 11, 2018

Harry Wilson's tackle said:
silly Sheffield accent.

At least they are capable of pronouncing their Ts in this part of the world.

Sent from my PRA-LX1 using Tapatalk

Harry Wilson's tackle · Dec 11, 2018

Nottseagull said:
At least they are capable of pronouncing their Ts in this part of the world.

Sent from my PRA-LX1 using Tapatalk

I take it then you'd be strongly opposed to a saucy French doctor

nickbrighton · Dec 11, 2018

Huge missed opportunity. The new showrunner had a massive lead in time for this series. It should have been great. Jodie was very good and the companions were ok, although I think 3 is too many. What let this series down badly was the rubbish storytlines, and bad scripts. I think it was the weakest series of all of "new who". The best episode was "Rosa" and even that was ruined by an unexplained alien doing some kind of "Quantum Leap" evil leaper kind of thing. I thought that that was the introduction of somekind of ongoing arc, but whoever he was he was easily disposed of and forgotten about with no real explanation of who and why.A few years ago this was "must see TV" now its, I'll catch it later on Iplayer Very poor 2/10

vegster · Dec 11, 2018

nickbrighton said:
Huge missed opportunity. The new showrunner had a massive lead in time for this series. It should have been great. Jodie was very good and the companions were ok, although I think 3 is too many. What let this series down badly was the rubbish storytlines, and bad scripts. I think it was the weakest series of all of "new who". The best episode was "Rosa" and even that was ruined by an unexplained alien doing some kind of "Quantum Leap" evil leaper kind of thing. I thought that that was the introduction of somekind of ongoing arc, but whoever he was he was easily disposed of and forgotten about with no real explanation of who and why.A few years ago this was "must see TV" now its, I'll catch it later on Iplayer Very poor 2/10

Yes, great at some points but not always consistent. The last episode was a bit odd especially when our pacifist Doctor happened to pick up some neural inhibitors, throat worn voice communicators and several GRENADES for their exploration !

Iggle Piggle · Dec 11, 2018

nickbrighton said:
Huge missed opportunity. The new showrunner had a massive lead in time for this series. It should have been great. Jodie was very good and the companions were ok, although I think 3 is too many. What let this series down badly was the rubbish storytlines, and bad scripts. I think it was the weakest series of all of "new who". The best episode was "Rosa" and even that was ruined by an unexplained alien doing some kind of "Quantum Leap" evil leaper kind of thing. I thought that that was the introduction of somekind of ongoing arc, but whoever he was he was easily disposed of and forgotten about with no real explanation of who and why.A few years ago this was "must see TV" now its, I'll catch it later on Iplayer Very poor 2/10

Good God. I only recently watched the Rosa one with my son and thought it was preachy, subtle as a sledgehammer and written in the style of somebody knocking something out on a friday afternoon. If that's as good as it gets the rest of it can get wiped from the sky planner.

Got something to say or just want fewer pesky ads? Join us... 😊

[TV] Dr Who

'The' Yaztromo

VERY part time moderator

Punxsatawney Phil

Well-known member

Well-known member

Well-known member

Well-known member

Todd Warrior

Harry Wilson's Tackle

Sanity Clause

Well-known member

Sanity Clause

Sanity Clause

Well-known member

Well-known member

Well-known member

Harry Wilson's Tackle

Well-known member

Sanity Clause

Well-known member

Share this page