[Football] *** Das offizielle Deutschland gegen Schweden thead. ***

B

blockhseagull

Well-known member

Jan 30, 2006

7,349

Southampton

• Jun 23, 2018

• #41

Saunders said:

It has to be clear and obvious it wasnt until replayed at a much much slower speed. If the referee was in doubt he could have asked for it he didnt though. It was the referees mistake it would still be the referees mistake and not given if it was binned.

Click to expand...

The VAR team should have informed him he needed to look at it ... why didn’t they ?

Correct it wouldn’t have been given without VAR... so that is exactly my point, if they aren’t correcting wrong decisions then get rid

 

KZNSeagull

Well-known member

Nov 26, 2007

19,791

Wolsingham, County Durham

• Jun 23, 2018

• #42

Saunders said:

Its not VAR its the referees mistake and it would have not been given without VAR being used as well. The question is do we want every single incident reviewed and the time it takes for that or not. Otherwise if its not clear at normal speed then sometimes they wont be given and they wont be reviewed.

Click to expand...

VAR is supposed to find clear and obvious mistakes. There have been far too many in this World Cup that it has not found (Kane x 2, the double rugby tackle on the Serb last night, this one just now etc) . It is not a case of wanting every decision reviewed, it is a case of the right decision being made. If the Ref had given that, VAR would not have overruled him, so we are still at the mercy of a crap Ref. VAR just makes the game look more crooked than it already is.

 

Bry Nylon

Test your smoke alarm

Helpful Moderator

Jul 21, 2003

19,835

Playing snooker

• Jun 23, 2018

• #43

blockhseagull said:

VAR is meant to review and tell ref if he has made a clear an obvious mistake. !!

He had... they didn’t.

I’m failing to see how VAR is improving the game as there have been a number of blatant decisions which haven’t been reviewed correctly. System is massively flawed and an absolute joke.

Isn’t improving the game and should be binned ASAP

Click to expand...

Agree. The VARs are just a bunch of full kit wankers.

 

S

Saunders

Well-known member

Oct 1, 2017

2,292

Brighton

• Jun 23, 2018

• #44

Bodian said:

Don't really think so. It looked pretty obvious from the very first replay and from the other angle at normal speed - which is precisely what VAR is meant to be looking at.

Click to expand...

They arent going to be constantly overulling the referee. I wasnt sure myself until I saw the replay and a different angle, the ref was quite far away. I am surprised he didnt ask for it which is why I say it was his mistake because he left the VAR team in a situation of deciding if it was clear enough.

 

Mellotron

I've asked for soup

Jul 2, 2008

31,826

Brighton

• Jun 23, 2018

• #45

Herr Tubthumper said:

very funny.

Click to expand...

I don’t get it...

Oh. Germany being utter shit and going out is very funny! Now I got it. Sorry sometimes the German sense of humour is how you say...

 

B

blockhseagull

Well-known member

Jan 30, 2006

7,349

Southampton

• Jun 23, 2018

• #46

Saunders said:

They arent going to be constantly overulling the referee. I wasnt sure myself until I saw the replay and a different angle, the ref was quite far away. I am surprised he didnt ask for it which is why I say it was his mistake because he left the VAR team in a situation of deciding if it was clear enough.

Click to expand...

The VAR team can’t overrule him... they should have told him to look at it

They didn’t ... which means it’s yet ANOTHER failure.

 

PILTDOWN MAN

Well-known member

NSC Patron

Sep 15, 2004

18,686

Hurst Green

• Jun 23, 2018

• #47

Herr Tubthumper said:

Bring on the champions!

Click to expand...

Traitor

 

Frutos

.

Helpful Moderator

NSC Patron

May 3, 2006

35,541

Northumberland

• Jun 23, 2018

• #48

Sweden 1-0 Germany

 

S

Saunders

Well-known member

Oct 1, 2017

2,292

Brighton

• Jun 23, 2018

• #49

blockhseagull said:

The VAR team can’t overrule him... they should have told him to look at it

They didn’t ... which means it’s yet ANOTHER failure.

Click to expand...

Telling him to look at it is overuling and they will only do that if they feel its an clear and obvious mistake.

TOOOOOOOOOOOOORRRRRRRRRRRRR

 

KZNSeagull

Well-known member

Nov 26, 2007

19,791

Wolsingham, County Durham

• Jun 23, 2018

• #50

Boom!

 

SweatyMexican

Well-known member

Mar 31, 2013

4,101

• Jun 23, 2018

• #51

Lovely finish

 

Bry Nylon

Test your smoke alarm

Helpful Moderator

Jul 21, 2003

19,835

Playing snooker

• Jun 23, 2018

• #52

Oh yes!!!

The sausage eaters are on their way home

 

Razzoo

Well-known member

Sep 11, 2011

5,295

N. Yorkshire

• Jun 23, 2018

• #53

Get in there, classy finish

 

swindonseagull

Well-known member

Aug 6, 2003

9,262

Swindon, but used to be Manila

• Jun 23, 2018

• #54

BOOM get in

 

brakespear

Doctor Worm

Feb 24, 2009

12,326

Sleeping on the roof

• Jun 23, 2018

• #55

yes!!!! 0-1.

 

PILTDOWN MAN

Well-known member

NSC Patron

Sep 15, 2004

18,686

Hurst Green

• Jun 23, 2018

• #56

Take that you krauts

 

1066familyman

Radio User

Jan 15, 2008

15,185

• Jun 23, 2018

• #57

Alright then...4-1

 

TSB

Captain Hindsight

Jul 7, 2003

17,666

Lansdowne Place, Hove

• Jun 23, 2018

• #58

Frutos said:

Sweden 1-0 Germany

Click to expand...

Germany are really crap this year.

 

Green Cross Code Man

Wunt be druv

Mar 30, 2006

19,704

Eastbourne

• Jun 23, 2018

• #59

Justice.

 

banjo

GOSBTS

Oct 25, 2011

13,243

Deep south

• Jun 23, 2018

• #60

Wouldn’t happen in Germany.