Got something to say or just want fewer pesky ads? Join us... 😊
[Albion] "You're black and you stink" Rodriquez comment to Bong? - FA say not proven
- Thread starter El Presidente
- Start date
Is it PotG?
Thrifty non-licker
Without getting bogged down with all of the legalities and whatnots, you read the accusation, look at the pics and form your opinion of what was or wasn't said in all likelihood.
I know my view, and others have theirs.
We move on.
I know my view, and others have theirs.
We move on.
As predicted
As predictable as a mild Newhaven winter.
Hungry Joe
SINNEN
Glad it's all over so we can move on. Would be a shame if this results in any lasting animosity between fans of both clubs, I've certainly got nothing against the other Albion. Yes, some of their fans are behaving very poorly over this, but can we say hand on heart it would be any different from some of our 'finest' if the tables were reversed? I think the only real conclusions anyone can draw from this is that Rodriguez bought a whole load of unnecessary shite down on himself by behaving like a five year-old, and that the internet (Twitter especially) gives a voice to absolute ********s who would be far better off doing something more constructive with their time.
Last edited:
albionalex
Well-known member
Rodriguez won't feel ''agrieved'' - He will be ''relieved'' that the ''Panel'' were unable to accept that it was proven.
Gaetan Bong knows what Jay Rodrigez said and the fact he could not prove it to the satifaction of the people hearing the case does not detract from the facts.
For me sadly I feel that Bong has been letdown and it sets a bench mark. If you have the propensity to make such remarks then do it outside of earshot and visibility of others and you have every likliehood of not being punished. This will stop others reporting such incidents because they will feel they need clear cut evidence to do so. And if they do that, they will be questioned for not reporting the incident at the time it happens.
I am really saddened by this outcome.
Thunder Bolt
Silly old bat
Yes, some prat who supports Barnsley has got a bee in his bonnet.
Seasider78
Well-known member
- Nov 14, 2004
- 5,938
Exactly how I feel about this
Hungry Joe
SINNEN
I don't agree. Bong doesn't 'know' what Rodriguez said, he thinks he knows. There are no absolutes in this case, as others have said, it's possible (and I now think likely) that both parties were telling their truth - Bong genuinely thought he heard what he heard and Rodriguez genuinely did not say what Bong thought he said exactly. No one will ever know for sure, but to claim one party is right when it can't be proven is not correct. Rodriguez may well feel aggrieved if he is telling the truth, even if he did behave like a tool in general. He should also feel very silly for behaving as he did with regards to the breath gesture.
Then you and I just have to disagree on this one. Gaetan doesn't think he heard what he heard. He heard it.
We have to move on because no amount of debate is going to change it now but I can't see many people reporting incidents in the future, which for me sets society and football back that little bit further on such issues.
Hungry Joe
SINNEN
Question - have you ever misheard something and been 100% convinced what you heard was right? If the answer to that is 'yes', as it surely must be, how can you claim such certainty in this case without any corroborating evidence?
Thunder Bolt
Silly old bat
The report
http://www.thefa.com/news/2018/apr/13/jay-rodriguez-decision-130418
If you read it, Bong knows what was said. His evidence includes 100% sure of what was said.
There is also evidence from two lip readers one for the FA and one for Rodriguez.
YES maybe 100 or so times in my life.
Have I ever heard someone say something and heard it correctly - YES every other statement made to me in my lifetime apart from those 100 or so mentioned above
Hungry Joe
SINNEN
So you accept then that it is possible that Bong misheard? It's not a numbers game.
Hungry Joe
SINNEN
I've read it. I've been 100% sure I've heard things before and been wrong, that doesn't make me liar, doesn't make Bong a liar, and crucially doesn't make Rodriguez a liar either. He MAY be a liar, but it is not proven, so therefore the decision is correct, surely.
This. Bong thinks he is 100% sure but it can’t be proven. He may be mistaken. If the boot was on the other foot we’d have been absolutely howling had the decision gone against our player.
Thunder Bolt
Silly old bat
I agree the decision is correct, because neither the FA nor Rodriguez's lip reader could see his mouth, because his fingers were in the way. That doesn't make Bong mistaken. One of the lip readers picked up the word garlic, and Bong speaks French, which ties in with the 'stink' accusation. Even if it wasn't the word black, there is still an element of nationalism about it.
I don't accept that it is possible because Gaetan Bong states that it was not possible that he misheard it.