Got something to say or just want fewer pesky ads? Join us... 😊

[Albion] Player ratings v Palace (h) - FA Cup



Hammer15

New member
Apr 20, 2016
272
Montclair, NJ
I don't put cup scores into the spreadsheet, so these ratings are just for fun. I'll join in today...

Krul 6
Schelotto 7
Hunemeier 7
Goldson 6
Bong 6
March 7
Kayal 8, MOM
Stephens 7.5
Izquierdo 7
Brown n/a
Hemed 6

Baldock 7
Propper 6
Murray 7
 


RM-Taylor

He's Magic.... You Know
Jan 7, 2006
15,267
Schelotto, Kayal, Stephens and Baldock were the outstanding players.
March is so inconsistent, in and out of the game, good in the final 10 mins or so.
Krul had nothing to do except collect the ball out the back of the net from a great strike by Sako.
Uwe was better than Goldson
 


djentist

New member
Aug 15, 2017
624
Krul 7

Schelotto 7
Hunemeier 7
Goldson 6
Bong 6

March 7
Kayal 8
Stephens 8
Izquierdo 7

Brown n/a

Hemed 6

Baldock 7
Propper 6
Murray 7

Pretty similar to yours, I don't do half ratings though so rounded the Stephens one up
 


British Bulldog

The great escape
Feb 6, 2006
10,889
I don't put cup scores into the spreadsheet, so these ratings are just for fun. I'll join in today...

Krul 6
Schelotto 7
Hunemeier 7
Goldson 6
Bong 6
March 7
Kayal 8, MOM
Stephens 7.5
Izquierdo 7
Brown n/a
Hemed 6

Baldock 7
Propper 6
Murray 7

Agree with that apart from March who I'd just give a 6
 


Bodian

Well-known member
May 3, 2012
11,599
Cumbria
Schelotto, Kayal, Stephens and Baldock were the outstanding players.
March is so inconsistent, in and out of the game, good in the final 10 mins or so.
Krul had nothing to do except collect the ball out the back of the net from a great strike by Sako.
Uwe was better than Goldson

Not tall enough??
 












Bladders

Twats everywhere
Jun 22, 2012
13,672
The Troubadour
Is March getting a 7 for the chipped free kick for the 2nd goal?

Cause that was about all he did all game


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 


Sheebo

Well-known member
Jul 13, 2003
29,226
Everyone marking Bong too low imo. Thought he was very good tonight...
 


Petee

Well-known member
Nov 22, 2010
3,031
Brighton
Krul 6

Schelotto 6.5
Goldson 7
Hunemeier 7
Bong 7.5

March 7
Stephens 6.5
Kayal 7.5
Izquierdo 7

Brown N/A

Hemed 7

Baldock 7
Propper 6
Murray 10 - Anything less is wrong.
 








big nuts

Well-known member
Jan 15, 2011
4,859
Hove
Krul - 6
Stiletto - 6
Bong - 7
Goodson - 6
Hunemeier - 7
Stephens - 8
Kayal - 9
March - 6
Izquierdo - 6
Hemed - 6
Brown na

Baldock - 7
Propper - 5
Murray - 8
 






dazzer6666

Well-known member
NSC Patreon
Mar 27, 2013
52,011
Burgess Hill
Krul - 6
Stiletto - 6
Bong - 7
Goodson - 6
Hunemeier - 7
Stephens - 8
Kayal - 9
March - 6
Izquierdo - 6
Hemed - 6
Brown na

Baldock - 7
Propper - 5
Murray - 8

This looks about right to me, possibly a bit generous for March who was stinking the place out in the first half.

When MOM was announced a loud voice just behind us said ‘Kayal ? He’s been shit all game’..........
 


Algernon

Well-known member
Sep 9, 2012
2,931
Newmarket.
History will show that in 2018 BHA knocked Crystal Phallus out of the FA Cup.
No matter the circumstances, It means we can remind them of this for years to come.
I reckon that alone is worth an extra point (at least) on each rating surely.
 






Harry Wilson's tackle

Harry Wilson's Tackle
NSC Patreon
Oct 8, 2003
49,341
Faversham
How many points did Conroy Goldstone get?
 





Paying the bills

Latest Discussions

Paying the bills

Paying the bills

Paying the bills

Albion and Premier League latest from Sky Sports


Top
Link Here