[Albion] Skalak and Murphy?

herecomesaregular · Dec 16, 2017

Murphy: at least can run at players well, with the ball, and works hard defensively (plus has a decent shot on him).

Skalak: can at least put in a decent ball, occasionally.

Izquierdo is so..... absent.

Knocky and March are simply off form and we've stuck with them both for a while now. People will say Murphy and Skalak aren't good enough but like Knocky and March they had plenty of good games in the Championship, so what gives?

Is it PotG? · Dec 16, 2017

herecomesaregular said:
Murphy: at least can run at players well, with the ball, and works hard defensively (plus has a decent shot on him).

Skalak: can at least put in a decent ball, occasionally.

Izquierdo is so..... absent.

Knocky and March are simply off form and we've stuck with them both for a while now. People will say Murphy and Skalak aren't good enough but like Knocky and March they had plenty of good games in the Championship, so what gives?

....and Baldrick. Don't forget Baldrick as an attacking threat. What gives?

theboybilly · Dec 16, 2017

herecomesaregular said:
Murphy: at least can run at players well, with the ball, and works hard defensively (plus has a decent shot on him).

Skalak: can at least put in a decent ball, occasionally.

Izquierdo is so..... absent.

Knocky and March are simply off form and we've stuck with them both for a while now. People will say Murphy and Skalak aren't good enough but like Knocky and March they had plenty of good games in the Championship, so what gives?

Leave Jose alone. He needs more game time not being a sub one week and subbed the next.

BN9 BHA · Dec 16, 2017

herecomesaregular said:
. People will say Murphy and Skalak aren't good enough

Murphy and Skalak aren't good enough. :wink:

mothy · Dec 16, 2017

Jose is fine if you ask me

herecomesaregular · Dec 16, 2017

bn9 bha said:
Murphy and Skalak aren't good enough.

Currently, compared to March, Knocky and Jose, I'm not so sure.

BN9 BHA · Dec 16, 2017

herecomesaregular said:
Currently, compared to March, Knocky and Jose, I'm not so sure.

Skalak wasn't as good as March and Knocky last season, what makes you think he will be better in the PL?
If Murphy was any good he would be on the bench, not a PL player I'm afraid.

Hyperion · Dec 16, 2017

herecomesaregular said:
Murphy: at least can run at players well, with the ball, and works hard defensively (plus has a decent shot on him).

Skalak: can at least put in a decent ball, occasionally.

Izquierdo is so..... absent.

Knocky and March are simply off form and we've stuck with them both for a while now. People will say Murphy and Skalak aren't good enough but like Knocky and March they had plenty of good games in the Championship, so what gives?

Thank the Lord you’re not the manager. Terrible assessment of player quality

Skint Gull · Dec 16, 2017

If Skalak and Murphy are the answer, the question is not a positive one...

Sent from my Moto G (4) using Tapatalk

herecomesaregular · Dec 16, 2017

bn9 bha said:
Skalak wasn't as good as March and Knocky last season, what makes you think he will be better in the PL?
If Murphy was any good he would be on the bench, not a PL player I'm afraid.

Because March and Knocky are really, really poor currently?

scooter1 · Dec 17, 2017

I watched Skalak against Barnet and he was shocking, if that's what he currently has to offer then his first team Albion career is over at this level. Murphy can beat a player, but doesn't offer much more and jumps out of so many tackles. Both will easily find new clubs, but are not PL players

jamie the seagull · Dec 17, 2017

Both will be offered out in January window.
Rangers want Murphy.
Skalák to anyone who will take.
Neither have a future here.

albionalex · Dec 17, 2017

https://www.thescottishsun.co.uk/sp...plotting-january-swoop-jamie-murphy-brighton/

BN9 BHA · Dec 17, 2017

herecomesaregular said:
Because March and Knocky are really, really poor currently?

We can go round in circles here

Skalak and Murphy would definitely not be a better option, I didn't think March was too bad yesterday, especially in the first half.
I wouldn't say either player is really, really poor TBF.

BUTTERBALL · Dec 17, 2017

Don't rate Skalak, not good enough in open play. I am surprised Murphy has dropped out of the picture, more than good enough to do a job off the bench.

BensGrandad · Dec 17, 2017

Perhaps we will keep them both for next season in the Championship, which is where I am certain we will be.

Trigger · Dec 17, 2017

Anyone suggesting Skalak should be anywhere near the first team squad bar the Palace Cup reserve match needs putting out of their misery in a quiet corner.

BensGrandad · Dec 17, 2017

Trigger said:
Anyone suggesting Skalak should be anywhere near the first team squad bar the Palace Cup reserve match needs putting out of their misery in a quiet corner.

Is anybody suggesting he should be?

bluenitsuj · Dec 17, 2017

I would rather have Murphy or Baldock on the bench than Brown. They are our players and will give 100% given the chance.

BensGrandad · Dec 17, 2017

bluenitsuj said:
I would rather have Murphy or Baldock on the bench than Brown. They are our players and will give 100% given the chance.

Not sure about Murphy but definitely Baldock.as he offers something different to Murray and Hemed.

Got something to say or just want fewer pesky ads? Join us... 😊

[Albion] Skalak and Murphy?

We're in the pipe, 5 by 5

Thrifty non-licker

Well-known member

DOCKERS

Well-known member

We're in the pipe, 5 by 5

DOCKERS

New member

New member

We're in the pipe, 5 by 5

How soon is now?

Well-known member

Well-known member

DOCKERS

East Stand Brighton Boyz

New member

Well-known member

New member

Listen to me!!!

New member

Share this page