[Albion] LoyaltyPointGate - discussion with the club

BBassic said:

Simple solution is to only add the loyalty points if the ticket is used / scanned at the turnstile.

I say 'simple' but it would require club resources which, I imagine, would be foisted onto us in the form of ST price increases.

Click to expand...

Bwian said:

I'd say the simple solution is for the club to admit they screwed up instead of blaming football fans doing what football fans do-using the system available to them. Then move on and make sure they don't screw up again.

Click to expand...

darkwolf666 said:

The proof was in the data as posted by Bozza, which indicated the top loyalty points owners were the biggest category of no shows.

Click to expand...

drew said:

The problem with this system is that you can have people who never go to away games but have had a season ticket for 17 years yet someone who has had a season ticket for 10 years and has regularly supported the club away from home is behind them in the pecking order for the glamour games.

I don't know because the stats aren't available but I would guess that the vast majority of fans in the top tier have been fans for quite a few years.

Click to expand...

Beach Hut said:

That got abandoned after the West Ham Cup Game cock up and quite rightly to

Click to expand...

Mellor 3 Ward 4 said:

I guess you didn't get a ticket for that one....?

Click to expand...

Tubby-McFat-Fuc said:

But with onlly 4 or 5000 STH at Withdean then I would imagine the top band would be limited to people who held season tickets at Withdean, so I doubt 5 or 20 years would make a lot of difference. Band two would probably start with people whose 1st ST was in the 1st season at the Amex.

There will always be unfairness for anyone who misses out. But loyalty to me should mean season tickets holders at the club.

Click to expand...

Neville's Breakfast said:

I thought only Amex season tickets count for loyalty points ? It doesn't go back any further.

Click to expand...

Tubby-McFat-Fuc said:

But with onlly 4 or 5000 STH at Withdean then I would imagine the top band would be limited to people who held season tickets at Withdean, so I doubt 5 or 20 years would make a lot of difference. Band two would probably start with people whose 1st ST was in the 1st season at the Amex.

There will always be unfairness for anyone who misses out. But loyalty to me should mean season tickets holders at the club.

Click to expand...

drew said:

I agree with your last comment but as has been mentioned, the LP scheme only takes into account STHs during the Amex years. That said, I would suggest that it is highly likely that the 4/5000 STHs from Withdean all bought a season for the first Amex season and subsequent ones so they are, if they have been travelling away regularly, still likely to form the bulk of the top tier.

Click to expand...

dazzer6666 said:

Anyone with a ST for 7 years who has done around 10 away games, plus maybe a couple of cup matches at 20pts each, in each of the last couple of seasons (given the halving of points each season those further back than that aren't worth a lot) will be in the top tier for the 3,000 seat games (190 + 70 + 35)

Click to expand...

Goldstone1976 said:

*Pedant alert* (if accurate).

I think the ST element of the LP is for the number of times one has renewed (or the number of complete seasons) by the start of the season in question. Thus the maximum ST component of the LP for this season is 180, not 190.

Click to expand...