Page 5 of 11 FirstFirst ... 2345678 ... LastLast
Results 41 to 50 of 107
  1. #41
    Members
    Join Date
    Dec 2003
    Location
    Estonia
    Posts
    356


    1 Not allowed!
    Usually those ratings make sense but from TV I saw many things differently:

    Ryan - 7. Couple of good saves, decent distribution, maybe ciuld have done a little bettee with Dunk's header.

    Bruno - 6. Alright but didn't offer much going forward.

    Dunk - 6. Should be higher if not that own goal.

    Duffy - 5. His mistake (back pass) was even poorer than Stephens's. Seemed more nervous than Dunk.

    Suttner - 7. All and all I thought he was best player from our back four. Had I wonderful volley towards Pröpper (just headed to corner by ManC defender).

    March - 7. Class but even he was isolated going forward.

    Stephens - 5. Will have better days.

    Pröpper - 5. Wasn't good but I don't think he was as bad as some describe. Will improve a lot.

    Murphy - 6. He might not be Manchester City class but I can see him outclassing lesser defences.

    Groß - 6. His set pieces were great, otherwise was a bit anonymous.

    Hemed - 5. Worked and ran well enough but just didn't have service. I think that even Lewandowski or Zlatan etc wouldn't have been able do offer much more with that kind of service againts that ManC team. Yes, Hemed wasn't great but I cannot understand the bashing here.

    Sent from my ONE A2003 using Tapatalk

    • North Stand Chat

      advertising
      Join Date: Jul 2003
      Posts: Lots

        


    • #42

      1 Not allowed!
      Quote Originally Posted by Triggaaar View Post
      This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote
      I'm very confident he won't get worse.
      Has there been a worse debut? Probably. But for a record signing?! He must have given the ball away in dangerous situations at least half a dozen times. It's one thing to not know your team mates, but surely he can recognise the colour of the shirt?

      Things can only get better...
      *JCL since 1976 - FA Cup final, replay and semi, two play-off finals, Hereford, three Championships, eight promotions, five relegations, four home stadiums*
    • #43

      0 Not allowed!
      Ryan 7.5
      Bruno 8.5 MOM
      Dunk 8 (would have been 9 but for OG)
      Duffy 8
      Suttner 6
      Stephens 6 (would have been 7 but mistake for goal)
      Propper 3
      March 7
      Brown 7 (looked prommising until injury)
      Gross 5
      Hemed 4

      Murphy 4
      Murray 6
      Knocky 7
      *JCL since 1976 - FA Cup final, replay and semi, two play-off finals, Hereford, three Championships, eight promotions, five relegations, four home stadiums*
    • #44
      tinky ****in winky sydney's Avatar
      Join Date
      Jul 2003
      Location
      town full of eejits
      Posts
      10,042


      0 Not allowed!
      Ryan 7
      Bruno 7.5
      Dunk 7
      Duffy 6
      Suttner 6.5
      Stephens 7
      Propper 4
      March 7.5
      Brown 5
      Gross 6
      Hemed 4.5

      Murphy 6
      Murray 5
      Kernockaert 6

      no individual slagging as the team are still sussing each other out ....vast improvement needed from Propper and Hemed although as i kept telling myself it was Citeh with their 500 million pound squad.....we turned attack into defence for the first goal with Murphy unsupported up front deciding to initiate the passage of the ball back to Ryan via Duffy , the resulting hoof seeing DS robbed by De Bruyne and setting up Aguero , Dunks header should have been saved really........all in all we gave the ball away far too much and really offered not a lot going forward but then again......it was Citeh......
      FLOUNDERING...!!!
    • #45
      Members Capricorn's Avatar
      Join Date
      Aug 2010
      Location
      Perth, Australia
      Posts
      314


      1 Not allowed!
      Ryan 8 - thought Ryan was very good today - although might have done better with the second goal

      Bruno 7 - have to admit I was unsure how Bruno would get on in the Prem but he more than held his own
      Suttner 7
      Dunk 8
      Duffy 7

      (Defence as a whole looked very solid considering we were playing Citeh)

      Stephens 5
      Propper 6 - I think people are being harsh on Propper, granted he had some sloppy moments, but he did seem to come into it later on in the game
      March 9 - March was a different class today. Absolute quality
      Brown 8 - for the short time he was on, he looked like an attacking threat

      Gross 5
      Hemed 4

      (Because of the way we set up, you can't really read much into the performances of Gross and Hemed, they were always going to be anonymous in this match)

      Murray 5
      Murphy 7
      Knockaert 7 - He's going to make a big difference when he's fully fit
    • #46
      Members
      Join Date
      Sep 2010
      Location
      Sydney, Australia
      Posts
      466


      6 Not allowed!
      Ryan - distribution ordinary and let in a goal he should have saved. How is that more than a 5 at best?

      Bruno - great relief. Sound defensively and one of only two players with any poise on the ball. 7

      Suttner - 6 Did fine

      Dunk 6 - caught out of position for both goals but gets bonus points for those long range passes

      Duffy 5 Lucky he didn't give away a goal

      Stephens 5 ordinary and did give away a goal

      Propper 4 oh dear. Ince would have showed more speed of thought and passing ability

      Murphy 6 Did better than Brown at keeping Walker quiet and got forward too

      March 8 Real class on the ball and solid defensively. Will attract a £25m bid in Jan if he keeps playing like that.

      Gross 5 - at least one beautiful pass and kept the shape defensively well

      Hemed 3 Too slow for the Championship. Why was he out there?


      Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
    • #47
      Members
      Join Date
      Nov 2007
      Location
      Sarisbury Green, Southampton
      Posts
      2,607


      0 Not allowed!
      Ryan - 7

      Bruno - 8
      Dunk - 6
      Duffy - 6
      Suttner - 5

      March - 7
      Stephens - 5
      Propper - 6
      Brown - n/a

      Gross - 6
      Hemed - 4

      Murphy - 5
    • #48
      Chrissy Hughton Fanboy Guinness Boy's Avatar
      Join Date
      Jul 2003
      Location
      Up and Coming Sunny Portslade
      Posts
      11,614


      0 Not allowed!
      Ryan 7
      Bruno 9 MOM
      Dunk 8
      Duffy 8
      Suttner 7
      Stephens 5
      Propper 2
      March 8
      Brown 7 (excellent but not on long enough)
      Gross 6 (but no service)
      Hemed 3

      Murphy 5

      No point ranking Murray and Knocky.

      Seriously underwhelming debut from a record signing who can hopefully only improve. We need a Premier League quality striker asap.
      Brighton But Only At Home

      It's a blog. About home games. And some other stuff.
    • #49
      Y.P.J spence's Avatar
      Join Date
      Oct 2014
      Location
      Non EU
      Posts
      5,279


      1 Not allowed!
      Quote Originally Posted by mreprice View Post
      This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote
      Ryan - distribution ordinary and let in a goal he should have saved. How is that more than a 5 at best?

      Bruno - great relief. Sound defensively and one of only two players with any poise on the ball. 7

      Suttner - 6 Did fine

      Dunk 6 - caught out of position for both goals but gets bonus points for those long range passes

      Duffy 5 Lucky he didn't give away a goal

      Stephens 5 ordinary and did give away a goal

      Propper 4 oh dear. Ince would have showed more speed of thought and passing ability

      Murphy 6 Did better than Brown at keeping Walker quiet and got forward too

      March 8 Real class on the ball and solid defensively. Will attract a £25m bid in Jan if he keeps playing like that.

      Gross 5 - at least one beautiful pass and kept the shape defensively well

      Hemed 3 Too slow for the Championship. Why was he out there?


      Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
      Bruno was better than March but otherwise i agree with everything else. Ryan doens't deserve more than a 5 for the reasons you say. Two games and two costly mistakes. Poor signing
      Kobanî liberated 26th Jan 2015 = Modern day Stalingrad
      RIP Ceylan Ozalp, 19
      https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0Zqu...dex=11&list=WL
    • #50
      On the BHA rollercoaster Icy Gull's Avatar
      Join Date
      Jul 2003
      Posts
      43,184


      0 Not allowed!
      Quote Originally Posted by Stat Brother View Post
      This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote
      I'm curious as to what benefit a fast Hemed would have been?

      The way I saw the game if Tomer was quick he'd have just been even further away from all his teammates.
      If we had a forward with pace there might have been someone in the box when Murphy made a breakaway down the wing only to end up with Albion players only just coming over the halfway line when he was in a position to cross.

      That's when..could have given us three points too
      Falmer, concrete proof that if you build it they will come

Bookmarks

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •