Player ratings against. dirty Leeds

Uh_huh_him · Mar 19, 2017

I haven't seen a thread anywhere.. Apologies if I've missed one.

I only listened to the game, so would welcome the views from those who attended/ watched.

Sussex Nomad · Mar 19, 2017

To be fair, we played ok. Unstuck by a non challenged opening goal and a silly mistake for the pen. Anyone that rates the players low don't really have a clue. Personally thought, other than the pen, Tomori fitted in very well.

Brighton Mod · Mar 19, 2017

I wouldn't necessarily mark down any individual player on last nights performance, but I would make a point about our lacklustre performance in the first half and the game plan set by the management team. There was some poor body language and some words had between players which I have not witnessed previously and no clear leader on the pitch, the forwards worked hard to close down and pressurise the Leeds defence, but the midfield struggled to gain a foothold.
I question the strategy of going away and playing with a defence game plan and accepting a loss, when we could play our normal game and probably score but would do no worse than last night.
But not dwelling on this result we need to get back to winning ways, so lets hope the management team will be a little more positive because i believe the defencive strategy last night affected the players and their approach to the game.

One Teddy Maybank · Mar 20, 2017

Still no ratings?
Here are mine - 6-average

Stockdale 6 - nothing to do
Tomori 7
Rosenoir 6
Dunk 6.5
Huenenmeier 8
Kayal 7
Stephens 6
Knockaert 6
Skalak 6
Baldock 6
Murray 6

March 7

Thought we did okay but nothing more. I may have been generous with Murray especially given the chances he missed, but at least he was in the position.

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

maltaseagull · Mar 20, 2017

I question the not starting of March. He is so effective when he does come on and perhaps rather than chasing a goal or more we may be in a position to replace him when we are in front if required.

amexer · Mar 20, 2017

Thought we played ok.
Big moments were penalty as have no doubt we would have been pushing for equaliser in last 10mins and still cant understand why Dunk didnt jump with Wood for goal

Machiavelli · Mar 20, 2017

amexer said:
Thought we played ok.
Big moments were penalty as have no doubt we would have been pushing for equaliser in last 10mins and still cant understand why Dunk didnt jump with Wood for goal

Wood was very canny with that headed goal. He dropped off just before the cross came in, and lost Dunk, while allowing himself the forward movement to attack the ball. Hopefully, Lewis will learn from that.

Machiavelli · Mar 20, 2017

One Teddy Maybank said:
Still no ratings?
Here are mine - 6-average

Stockdale 6 - nothing to do
Tomori 6.5 -- loses a point for that naive challenge
Rosenoir 6
Dunk 6.5
Huenemeier 7.5
Kayal 8 MotM -- tigerish and tenacious, hope that injury isn't too bad
Stephens 5 -- had his poorest game for a while
Knockaert 6 -- another frustrating finish, he needs to be less selfish
Skalak 5
Baldock 6
Murray 6

March 7

Thought we did okay but nothing more. I may have been generous with Murray especially given the chances he missed, but at least he was in the position.

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Yours aren't too far off mine, so I've amended yours in your original post. Agree with your comment about Murray. It was close, we probably had more good opportunities than them.

dazzer6666 · Mar 20, 2017

Stockdale 6 - nothing he could do about the first goal, distribution good
Tomori 6.5 - apart from the lunge, did well defensively, although doesn't offer much going forward, we missed Bruno as an outlet and I think Knocky missed him too
Rosenoir 6.5
Dunk 6 - at (some at least) fault for their first
Huenemeier 8 - brilliant performance, some great tackles and so composed on the ball. Easy MOM for me
Kayal 7 - getting back to his snappy best. One great run in the first half
Stephens 6.5
Knockaert 6 - one of those (away) days again. Some bad decisions (one in particular after a good run when he should have squared it to Murray)
Skalak 6 - solid enough
Baldock 6 - industrious as usual but not one of his better games
Murray 6 - dominated their CBs in the air but missed two good chances

March - 6 - looked lively
Norwood/Akpom - 5 - no impact

We weren't bad at all, was a tight game away to a pretty decent team and their striker took his chances, ours didn't. Could easily have been 2-0 the other way on another day.

Petee · Mar 20, 2017

From watching on TV

Stockdale 6
Tomori 7
Hunemeier 8 MOTM
Dunk 6
Rosenior 6.5
Knockaert 6.5
Kayal 7
Stephens 6
Skalak 6.5
Murray 5.5
Baldock 6

March 7
Akpom 5
Norwood 6

Giraffe · Mar 20, 2017

Stockdale 6 - nothing to do so hard to rate him. Could he have come for the cross for the first goal, maybe, but probably not.
Tomori 6 - a generally impressive performance given the importance of the game, but loses marks for a reckless lunge for the penalty which wasn't needed.
Rosenoir 6 - average
Dunk 7 - always looks more stretched when not alongside Duffy
Huenenmeier 7 - decent enough performance
Kayal 8 - my man of the match, put in a very hard and capable shift and won a lot of the ball
Stephens 6 - less convincing than normal, went missing for a lot of the game and didn't use the ball very well
Knockaert 6 - one decent run, but otherwise supply to him was restricted well by Leeds. Stephens failed to bring him into the game enough
Skalak 6 - average
Baldock 6 - average, not much service, but worked hard as ever
Murray 6 - our only threat, but sadly didn't take either of the two great opportunities he had

March 7 - as always looked great off the bench. More direct than any of our other wing options and could have created a goal or two with a bit more luck
Norwood 6 - not on long enough to judge, but in the limited time he was there he didn't have the ball in the right areas

DavidinSouthampton · Mar 20, 2017

Giraffe said:
Stockdale 6 - nothing to do so hard to rate him. Could he have come for the cross for the first goal, maybe, but probably not.
Tomori 6 - a generally impressive performance given the importance of the game, but loses marks for a reckless lunge for the penalty which wasn't needed.
Rosenoir 6 - average
Dunk 7 - always looks more stretched when not alongside Duffy
Huenenmeier 7 - decent enough performance
Kayal 8 - my man of the match, put in a very hard wormking and capable shift and won a lot of the ball
Stephens 6 - less convincing than normal, went missing for a lot of the game and didn't use the ball very well
Knockaert 6 - one decent run, but otherwise supply to him was restricted well by Leeds. Stephens failed to bring him into the game enough
Skalak 6 - average
Baldock 6 - average, not much service, but worked hard as ever
Murray 6 - our only threat, but sadly didn't take either of the two great opportunities he had

March 7 - as always looked great off the bench. More direct than any of our other wing options and could have created a goal or two with a bit more luck
Norwood 6 - not on long enough to judge, but in the limited time he was there he didn't have the ball in the right areas

Is wormking like the Lion King but smaller and less roary?

Is it PotG? · Mar 20, 2017

Giraffe said:
Stephens 6 - less convincing than normal, went missing for a lot of the game and didn't use the ball very well
Knockaert 6 - one decent run, but otherwise supply to him was restricted well by Leeds. Stephens failed to bring him into the game enough

That'll be it, Knocky has another bang average away and it's down to Stephens. Yes, I was there.

Giraffe · Mar 20, 2017

DavidinSouthampton said:
Is wormking like the Lion King but smaller and less roary?

Oh! Yes it is. And appropriate given his smaller demeanour!

Giraffe · Mar 20, 2017

Is it PotG? said:
That'll be it, Knocky has another bang average away and it's down to Stephens. Yes, I was there.

I was also there. Although not sure that's relevant.

My point is teams (other than Derby) are working out that the way to stop Knocky is not to let him have the ball. It's obvious (unless you are Steve McClaren) and this doesn't necessarily mean that Knocky has had a bad game.

Is it PotG? · Mar 20, 2017

Giraffe said:
I was also there. Although not sure that's relevant.

My point is teams (other than Derby) are working out that the way to stop Knocky is not to let him have the ball. It's obvious (unless you are Steve McClaren) and this doesn't necessarily mean that Knocky has had a bad game.

The point of the presence part was I was waiting for the question. I love AK in full flow as much as any fan, but many recent games (especially away) should be in the '3' score area.

Guinness Boy · Mar 20, 2017

Giraffe said:
I was also there. Although not sure that's relevant.

My point is teams (other than Derby) are working out that the way to stop Knocky is not to let him have the ball. It's obvious (unless you are Steve McClaren) and this doesn't necessarily mean that Knocky has had a bad game.

Watched on the TV and the commentators made the point that we needed to get Knockaert more involved, more than Leeds cutting off the supply. I honestly think it's a bit of both. We seem to set up much more conservatively away. At home Knockaert is really at his most dangerous 30 yards from our own goal when our opponents' attack breaks down. We basically scored the same goal three times over against Reading for example, whereas at Leeds we never looked like hitting them on the break at pace.

I also think we missed Bruno in this respect, he links up with Knocky far better than Tomori.

Otherwise the marks on this thread are about right, Uwe and Kayal the two players who stood out, Stephens poor and Tomori doing nothing wrong except the penalty whilst generally not being Bruno.

hampshirebrightonboy · Mar 20, 2017

amexer said:
Thought we played ok.
Big moments were penalty as have no doubt we would have been pushing for equaliser in last 10mins and still cant understand why Dunk didnt jump with Wood for goal

Wood pushed Dunk away just before the ball got to him

Seagull over NZ · Mar 20, 2017

Not only was Wood's movement good, he gives a little "hand-off" to Dunk's chest at the key moment which stops Dunk from getting close to him.

beefypigeon · Mar 20, 2017

Standouts for me were Huenemeier, Kayal and Tomori (despite his one error in giving away the penalty). Would give them all a 7.5 or 8 out of 10.

The rest were OK. It was a fairly decent performance all in all, and on another day we actually could have stolen a victory. On the balance of play I don't feel Leeds warranted the 3 points.

Got something to say or just want fewer pesky ads? Join us... 😊

Player ratings against. dirty Leeds

Well-known member

Well-known member

Its All Too Beautiful

Well-known member

Well-known member

Well-known member

Well-known member

Well-known member

Well-known member

Well-known member

VERY part time moderator

Well-known member

Thrifty non-licker

VERY part time moderator

VERY part time moderator

Thrifty non-licker

Tofu eating wokerati

Well-known member

Well-known member

Well-known member

Share this page