DavidRyder
Well-known member
- Jul 23, 2013
- 2,885
Would be delighted to see Huddersfield go up, provided it's not at our expense! I think a Premier League with us both in it next season would be refreshing.
Got something to say or just want fewer pesky ads? Join us... 😊
A Huddersfield fan offering a different perspective
- Thread starter elliotthtafc
- Start date
"The transformation has also seen Town become a side capable of not only playing some of the most attractive, exciting expansive football in the entire division but also a side that can grind it out, compete and work for their success when they need too."
See me.
See me.
elliotthtafc
New member
- Mar 10, 2017
- 9
- Thread starter
- #23
Likewise, I mentioned in the original post, most Huddersfield fans would be fully behind Brightoon going up if we were languishing in mid-table.
1. My piece is about my experiences as a Huddersfield fan reflecting on our season, if it was a much broader review of the Championship season as a whole then I'd be much more inclined to reference other teams.
2. I don't think it's arrogant, I think you've missed the point as you said there is nothing remotely unique about a squad playing for each other, however, the quote you refer to is far more than just a squad playing for each other. Throughout my entire life as a Huddersfield fan, there has been tensions between fans,there has been financial mismanagent and groups within the club's hierarchy with their own personal interests. Until this season there has never been a collective unity between the club hierarchy, club personnel and fans. There has been disputes over stadium ownership, we have gone through administration and faced relegation (albeit I was only eight years old in 2003). So what I refer to is unique to me (personally) as it is the first time that I have experienced such unity as a Huddersfield fan.
3. Fair point, can't really disagree with that.
4. I think the vast majority of fans and pundits believe you will be promoted automatically. Of course, a minority of fans who aren't blinded by bias may believe we can do it but an overwhelmingly majority don't.
5. Considering that this is only my second ever blog, I will address any formatting issues.
Anyway thank you for your harsh but fair criticisms. I've taken all of them on board.
elliotthtafc
New member
- Mar 10, 2017
- 9
- Thread starter
- #24
Why would I? It was a blog written about Huddersfield's season and my experiences as a Huddersfield fan. As I mention in the comment above, having gone through a Steve Bruce tenure that left the club on the brink of liquidation and disputes over Stadium ownership which has been equally damaging- I have never experienced any form of unity as a Huddersfield fan. I don't speak as an expert of Championship football or as an expert of Brighton & Hove Albion so I can happily concede that I don't know much about Brighton & Hove Albion, I expect you're exactly the same about Huddersfield Town. I speak merely as a fan.
elliotthtafc
New member
- Mar 10, 2017
- 9
- Thread starter
- #26
It was an insight into our season through the experiences of a football fan. If you acknowledge that it is an emotive piece then I'm not sure what you were expecting in terms of facts supported by evidence.
I must admit I did feel a bit dirty writing that word.
elliotthtafc
New member
- Mar 10, 2017
- 9
- Thread starter
- #27
Considering that in the very first post, I openly wish you gain promotion to the Premier League, I don't think there is an arrogance, we acknowledge we're punching above our weight and in that sense, it is special as it was for Brighton last season, after finishing 19th the season before.
Addressing your second point, don't you think there is a flaw in result-based rather than performance based data analysis. For example, taking your usage of evidence, why haven't Reading dropped out of the playoff places considering that they have the highest goals against and the worst goal difference. Winning by a single goal margin is the same as winning by five. I'm sure you and all Brighton fans would take ten 1-0 wins from now until the end of the season. On extremely limited resources, a net spend of £2 million, Wagner is performing all sorts of miracles. I'm not sure how you see a barely positive goal difference as a genuine reason why he isn't...
elliotthtafc
New member
- Mar 10, 2017
- 9
- Thread starter
- #28
I really appreciate this Dave, it has been quite a baptism of fire.
I think my use of the word unique has been misinterpreted, it was a unique experience to me. Not that the club was unique or special in having this unity.
All the best for the remainder of the season.
elliotthtafc
New member
- Mar 10, 2017
- 9
- Thread starter
- #29
I think the feeling is completely mutual. After last season, you deserved to go up and you deserve to go up again, if we weren't in contention then I would be backing Brighton 100%
Wagner has built a team using German second division players, one or two other foreign mercenaries and a few British players, got them as fit as fleas, adopted gengenpressing as the modus operandi, they stop other teams from playing for 95+ minutes and invariably nick a win by the odd goal, often in the 90th minute. Credit where its due, if dosh is in short supply it's a bloody good way of building a side to compete. And they won't go away because they're essentially German and it will be a ****ing blitzkreig and donner und blitzen all the way to the end of the season.
Normal Rob
Well-known member
does your team barbour only know one cut?
Stato
Well-known member
- Dec 21, 2011
- 6,585
This could be seen as a slightly insensitive comment to make to fans whose team failed to go up last year by two goals. However, if you're sure this is the case, could you please let the Football League know. There may be a chance we should have finished above Middlesbrough on alphabetical order.
Publius Ovidius
Well-known member
I take it due to your post and recent ones, you don't like Germans?
- Apr 5, 2014
- 23,585
Elliott, take a look at different theme settings for your page. I use the 'morning after' theme in Wordpress and also make use of categories and other sub divisions. See link below.
I'm loathed to be too critical of what you have written as it is something you appear to have recently started.
I would simply say that the article would probably have more roundness and flow if it took the reader on a journey. In this case from the lowest point of last year to now. At times it seems to restate previous points in a slightly different way. To keep a reader it is important to present something new each paragraph.
Tell folk about players who have made a difference and why. Who is David Wagner ? (assume folk don't know). Present the atmosphere around the area through tales of a match day. There's nothing like stepping into a frame rather than observing it blind through someone else's description.
I wouldn't tell you what to write or the intricacies of how to do it in detail. My own writing is very 'left field' and has a different follower interest. I do have an Albion section though.
What I would say though is that it is very readable with a sensible use of language.
That places you streets ahead of our most vocal self styled journalist on NSC....
Keep it up.
I'm willing to go as far as calling it unique much like Huddersfield side.
Official Old Man
Uckfield Seagull
Fair blog from a supporter.
On paper, and taking each game at a time, you have to think HT can win all their remaining fixtures.
There will (I hope) be a slip up. Just hope for their sake that they don't do an Albion and fall apart in the play-offs.
Third place on what could be 90 points will be gut wrenching.
On paper, and taking each game at a time, you have to think HT can win all their remaining fixtures.
There will (I hope) be a slip up. Just hope for their sake that they don't do an Albion and fall apart in the play-offs.
Third place on what could be 90 points will be gut wrenching.
Don't take it to heart, Elliott - you did ASK for feedback.
For a guy starting out, its a very decent effort.
On the 'unique' thing - had you just written "unique in our club's recent history" or something - every reader would have understood what you meant, rather than seeing it as placing your club somehow above all others (in respect of togetherness) - something that was sure to grate with non-partisan readers.
I appreciate that you wrote it with a Terriers audience in mind, but you did just post it on a Brighton fans' site.
Good luck, with your writing
Ron Manager
Oooh, wasn't it?
To be Frank, it wan't a bad early effort.
