lizard
Well-hung member
- Jul 14, 2005
- 3,335
Would love to see Wilson from the start, just like everyone else but think other than Calde it'll be an unchanged lineup. If it ain't broken don't fix it!
Got something to say or just want fewer pesky ads? Join us... 😊
Starting XI for Charlton
- Thread starter ballboys
- Start date
Would love to see Wilson from the start, just like everyone else but think other than Calde it'll be an unchanged lineup. If it ain't broken don't fix it!
sussex_guy2k2
Well-known member
- Jun 6, 2014
- 3,767
Totally agree with this. Unfortunately it's probably time for Hemed to have a couple of games out to try and regain his confidence. Personally I'd want Uwe back instead of Greer based on the last two games, but I suspect Greer will keep his place which isn't the end of the world by any stretch.
BensGrandad
New member
Are you serious Greer has been a revelation since coming back? If Uwe is recalled surely it will be for LD not GG.
Withdean11
Well-known member
Absolutely this.
Marshy
Well-known member
Calde for Rosenior clearly.
Ive given it a lot of thought, and as much as I want Bobby to start I would go with Hemed and Wilson.
Hes working bloody hard and a bit of luck will change everything for Hemed, it seems a good opportunity to get back to scoring ways against Charlton perhaps.
I also think Hemed isnt really the sort to change a game from the bench unlike Bobby has proven too this season already.
Ive given it a lot of thought, and as much as I want Bobby to start I would go with Hemed and Wilson.
Hes working bloody hard and a bit of luck will change everything for Hemed, it seems a good opportunity to get back to scoring ways against Charlton perhaps.
I also think Hemed isnt really the sort to change a game from the bench unlike Bobby has proven too this season already.
Marshy
Well-known member
Looking forward to saturday greatly 
Not sure how dropping Hemed will help him regain his confidence?
Mackenzie
Old Brightonian
Team to hammer Charlton
Stockdale
Bruno-Dunk-Greer-Calderon
March-Stephens-Kayal-Murphy
Hemed-Wilson
Subs: Zamora +6
Stockdale
Bruno-Dunk-Greer-Calderon
March-Stephens-Kayal-Murphy
Hemed-Wilson
Subs: Zamora +6
People saying things like 'if we start Hemed he'll get the goal he needs' and 'when we're 3 up bring the youth players on' clearly haven't been watching the Championship very long.
This Charlton side beat Sheffield Wednesday and Birmingham, recently. There are no easy games in this league whatsoever.
We've not beaten anyone by more than the single goal, not even Rotherham, who are below Charlton in the table.
Bobby and Wilson for me, Calde LB, and Hemed to replace Bobby on around the 60 minute mark.
This Charlton side beat Sheffield Wednesday and Birmingham, recently. There are no easy games in this league whatsoever.
We've not beaten anyone by more than the single goal, not even Rotherham, who are below Charlton in the table.
Bobby and Wilson for me, Calde LB, and Hemed to replace Bobby on around the 60 minute mark.
Stockdale
Bruno-Dunk-Greer-Calderon
March-Stephens-Kayal-Murphy
Hemed-Zamora
I cant see why Hughton will change a winning team, Dropping Hemed would be a huge knock to his confidence and Zamora is on fire at the moment so dropping him would be a silly move.
Bruno-Dunk-Greer-Calderon
March-Stephens-Kayal-Murphy
Hemed-Zamora
I cant see why Hughton will change a winning team, Dropping Hemed would be a huge knock to his confidence and Zamora is on fire at the moment so dropping him would be a silly move.
Discodoktor
Active member
For Charlton I reckon it will be Hemed and Bobby again. Then Wilson comes on.
It's a mentality where you can have impact subs and make the most of what you got.
Then for Derby it will be Bobby and Wilson. (Unless Hemed scores in the Charlton game).
Put the throttle on straight away.
It's a mentality where you can have impact subs and make the most of what you got.
Then for Derby it will be Bobby and Wilson. (Unless Hemed scores in the Charlton game).
Put the throttle on straight away.
sussex_guy2k2
Well-known member
- Jun 6, 2014
- 3,767
Just a personal opinion - as I said, it isn't the end of the world if Greer keeps his place. But yes, I am serious. I certainly haven't seen the form you're describing since he's returned to the team.
sussex_guy2k2
Well-known member
- Jun 6, 2014
- 3,767
Well you don't sell it to him as "you're being dropped", unless of course he's the type of player that reacts well to criticism and you want to force him to reflect on his game. But of course having time out of the spotlight, particularly for a striker that isn't scoring goals, will help certain players regain their confidence.
Anyway, that was just my personal opinion for what I'd do. Hughton will go with Zamora and Hemed because he doesn't like to change his first 11 around unless absolutely necessary.
Creative selection of the untried right winger at left back.
Dick Knights Mumm
Take me Home Falmer Road
It was definitely correct for Birmingham We don't want to put pressure on Wilson. Enjoy your football and the goals will come.
Blue Valkyrie
Not seen such Bravery!
I am now persuaded by the argument that we need as many minutes as possible from Bobby for Derby and QPR away, so would have him on the bench for this one, and start with Hemed and Wilson.