How is Liam?

Shropshire Seagull · Nov 29, 2015

I was watching a stream so had the benefit of a couple of slo-mo replays from different angles.
Defo knee, which looked to hyper-extend [bend in the wrong direction] sideways so my money would be on medial knee ligaments.
Key is extent of damage, strain, small tear, rupture [aka grade 1 / 2 / 3] which will dictate recovery time.
Unless there is a scanner in the locker / dressing room - won't know the detail.
Pointless guessing - wait and see .....

portslade seagull · Nov 29, 2015

Hopefully only something minor

Freddie Goodwin. · Nov 29, 2015

We could do without any knee-jerk reactions.

dazzer6666 · Nov 29, 2015

Shropshire Seagull said:
I was watching a stream so had the benefit of a couple of slo-mo replays from different angles.
Defo knee, which looked to hyper-extend [bend in the wrong direction] sideways so my money would be on medial knee ligaments.
Key is extent of damage, strain, small tear, rupture [aka grade 1 / 2 / 3] which will dictate recovery time.
Unless there is a scanner in the locker / dressing room - won't know the detail.
Pointless guessing - wait and see .....

CH already said medial knee ligaments last night. Hopefully a grade 1, 2 at worst.

Machiavelli · Nov 29, 2015

Mellor 3 Ward 4 said:
On the subject of TK racing out to him, from our players only Bruno went over to Liam, plus Bobby had a word on the way off the pitch, the rest all went over to the bench.

Perhaps they knew it was bad, and didn't want to lose concentration?

All this says something about Bruno. It was him that was consoling Texieira when he broke his leg too.
Bruno's not just flair, he's a gent too. The Calde love-in might just have deflected attention away from this.

Eeyore · Nov 29, 2015

DarrenFreemansPerm said:
He's previously played right back, I guess he's an option if nothing else. Having never seen him play a single minute of football I'd back him to be a better option than Chicksen.

He was in the Fourth Division 'team of the season' last year. Granted, it's a much lower level, but he must be pretty talented.

edna krabappel · Nov 29, 2015

dazzer6666 said:
CH already said medial knee ligaments last night. Hopefully a grade 1, 2 at worst.

Did he say medial then? I only heard him talking about knees. If it's medial, that's generally a lot better than a cruciate, isn't it?

Monkey Man · Nov 29, 2015

Mellor 3 Ward 4 said:
On the subject of TK racing out to him, from our players only Bruno went over to Liam, plus Bobby had a word on the way off the pitch, the rest all went over to the bench.

Perhaps they knew it was bad, and didn't want to lose concentration?

I'd forgotten this. It did strike me as odd - the injury looked very bad to me, and normally in these situations players surround the guy on the ground. Maybe our players sensed it wasn't as serious as it might have looked, or perhaps as you say just wanted to stay focused on the job. But it was a strange few minutes.

Bob! · Nov 29, 2015

edna krabappel said:
Did he say medial then? I only heard him talking about knees. If it's medial, that's generally a lot better than a cruciate, isn't it?

Yes he did

dazzer6666 · Nov 29, 2015

edna krabappel said:
Did he say medial then? I only heard him talking about knees. If it's medial, that's generally a lot better than a cruciate, isn't it?

Apparently so. If its an ACL your fooked for months.

Watching the highlights, he didn't look too distressed on the stretcher either. Hoping it was all precautionary, he's been bloody magnificent so far and seems like a top fella too. CH didn't seem hugely concerned. Let's wait for official news (although we rarely seem to get any)

Sheebo · Nov 29, 2015

Monkey Man said:
I'd forgotten this. It did strike me as odd - the injury looked very bad to me, and normally in these situations players surround the guy on the ground. Maybe our players sensed it wasn't as serious as it might have looked, or perhaps as you say just wanted to stay focused on the job. But it was a strange few minutes.

They could've just got a loud shout from the bench to use the time for some quick instructions...

Monkey Man · Nov 29, 2015

sheebo said:
They could've just got a loud shout from the bench to use the time for some quick instructions...

Yeah, that would make sense. You'd imagine that Liam would be a popular member of the squad and the natural reaction would be to see if he was OK. But given there was nothing the players themselves could do it would make sense to get some instructions. Though from memory I don't think they all went over to the dug-out.

seagullwedgee · Nov 29, 2015

Medial crucial ligament injury. 5 weeks min, more like 6 to 7.

Easy 10 · Nov 29, 2015

Now that we've got rid of Dr Mengele in the treatment room, I'm a little more optimistic of having him back this side of Easter.

Blue Valkyrie · Nov 30, 2015

seagullwedgee said:
Medial crucial ligament injury. 5 weeks min, more like 6 to 7.

Bong back in 7 weeks from now if the initial estimate was correct, so looking like a race to see which of them is back first.

Shropshire Seagull · Nov 30, 2015

seagullwedgee said:
Medial crucial ligament injury. 5 weeks min, more like 6 to 7.

Completely dependent on severity - a rupture [snap] will be significantly longer than a strain or a small tear.
Needs a scan to determine, only then can you put a recovery time guesstimate on it .....

Sheebo · Nov 30, 2015

seagullwedgee said:
Medial crucial ligament injury. 5 weeks min, more like 6 to 7.

Guess or inside info?

The Stout Yeoman · Nov 30, 2015

I'm surprised we dont know the full extent of the injury ... the ever responsible Sky Sports were putting the injury out as a broken leg at half time on Saturday ....

Got something to say or just want fewer pesky ads? Join us... 😊

How is Liam?

Well-known member

Well-known member

Well-known member

Well-known member

Well-known member

Colonel Hee-Haw of Queen's Park

Well-known member

Your support is not that great

Coffee Buyer

Well-known member

Well-known member

Your support is not that great

Well-known member

Brain dead MUG SHEEP

Not seen such Bravery!

Well-known member

Well-known member

Master Farter

Share this page