Paul McShane- Could do a job?

Stat Brother

Well-known member

NSC Patron

Jul 11, 2003

73,735

West west west Sussex

• May 28, 2015

• #21

Justice said:

Would be better than Halford

Click to expand...

Plus id rather buy a bike off McShane.

 

Simster

"the man's an arse"

Jul 7, 2003

54,207

Surrey

• May 28, 2015

• #22

Stat Brother said:

Plus id rather buy a bike off McShane.

Click to expand...

You've probably only used that joke about 25 times now. Being kind, it was mildly amusing on maybe the first three occasions. Could you refrain from using it from now on?

 

Hiney

Super Moderator

Helpful Moderator

Jul 5, 2003

19,396

Penrose, Cornwall

• May 28, 2015

• #23

Simster said:

You've probably only used that joke about 25 times now. Being kind, it was mildly amusing on maybe the first three occasions. Could you refrain from using it from now on?

Click to expand...

 

J

Jim Bob

New member

Dec 6, 2014

413

• May 28, 2015

• #24

McShane is a good option if you ask me, Liam Rosenior would do a job also

 

F

Funnell

Member

Jan 10, 2012

59

• May 28, 2015

• #25

Watched Hull's final game of the season, he was impressive - really committed, throwing himself at everything. He might be lacking technically a bit but we could do worse on a free.

 

B

BensGrandad

New member

Jul 13, 2003

72,015

Haywards Heath

• May 28, 2015

• #26

Jim Bob said:

McShane is a good option if you ask me, Liam Rosenior would do a job also

Click to expand...

Thats a good shout for right back as younger and quicker than Bruno and Calderon. I am not sure which one I would want least McShane or Halford not much to chose between them.

 

jameswestport

New member

Sep 7, 2011

927

• May 28, 2015

• #27

Would be absolute coup if we could get him!

 

Pavilionaire

Well-known member

Jul 7, 2003

30,586

• May 28, 2015

• #28

He fell out publicly with Steve Bruce over the Christmas period. Even so, I'm surprised Hull have let him go, I'm sure he'll do really well in the Championship.

 

Pavilionaire

Well-known member

Jul 7, 2003

30,586

• May 28, 2015

• #29

BensGrandad said:

Thats a good shout for right back as younger and quicker than Bruno and Calderon. I am not sure which one I would want least McShane or Halford not much to chose between them.

Click to expand...

McShane is a far superior player to Halford.

 

8ace

Banned

Jul 21, 2003

23,811

Brighton

• May 28, 2015

• #30

Doesn't McShane do long throw-ins as well

 

Stat Brother

Well-known member

NSC Patron

Jul 11, 2003

73,735

West west west Sussex

• May 28, 2015

• #31

Pavilionaire said:

McShane is a far superior player to Halford.

Click to expand...

Plus id rather buy replacement windscreen wipers from McShane.

Happy now.

 

B

BensGrandad

New member

Jul 13, 2003

72,015

Haywards Heath

• May 28, 2015

• #32

Pavilionaire said:

McShane is a far superior player to Halford.

Click to expand...

I have yet to be convinced about either.

 

Pavilionaire

Well-known member

Jul 7, 2003

30,586

• May 28, 2015

• #33

BensGrandad said:

I have yet to be convinced about either.

Click to expand...

Last weekend McShane and the Hull defence kept Champions League-bound Man Utd to just one shot on target all game. When is the last time Halford could say that?

 

O

ofco8

Well-known member

May 18, 2007

2,388

Brighton

• May 28, 2015

• #34

Surf's Up said:

For god's sake - look forwards not bloody backwards - NO!!

Click to expand...

This

 

B

BensGrandad

New member

Jul 13, 2003

72,015

Haywards Heath

• May 28, 2015

• #35

Pavilionaire said:

Last weekend McShane and the Hull defence kept Champions League-bound Man Utd to just one shot on target all game. When is the last time Halford could say that?

Click to expand...

When was the last time he had the opportunity by playing against them.. Having said that Man Utd had done their work so didnt need to raise their game plus Hulls inspiration was Michael Dawson.

 

Pavilionaire

Well-known member

Jul 7, 2003

30,586

• May 28, 2015

• #36

BensGrandad said:

When was the last time he had the opportunity by playing against them.. Having said that Man Utd had done their work so didnt need to raise their game plus Hulls inspiration was Michael Dawson.

Click to expand...

Er, the fact he hasn't had that opportunity suggests he hasn't been Prem quality for some time now.

By Steve Bruce's admission they got relegated because they didn't score enough goals - scoreless in 17 matches. I thought McShane did OK in the games I saw him play in this season.

 

J

Jim Bob

New member

Dec 6, 2014

413

• May 28, 2015

• #37

If its a straight choice between Halford and Mcshane it has to be Mcshane for me.

 

Stat Brother

Well-known member

NSC Patron

Jul 11, 2003

73,735

West west west Sussex

• May 28, 2015

• #38

Not forgetting the cold cynical money aspect.

The only way Tony isn't in even greater debt, is selling players.

McShane, Zamora et al are only ever going to take money from the club.

Why land yourself with a stupidly high debt that will never generate a single penny back?

 

The Kid Frankie

New member

Sep 5, 2012

2,082

• May 28, 2015

• #39

If the wages were sensible then he would be a very good signing in my opinion. Personally I think he is easily good enough to continue playing in the Prem, at least as a squad player. I think he will end up at somewhere like Leicester.

 

ditchy

a man with a sound track record as a source of qua

Jul 8, 2003

5,209

brighton

• May 28, 2015

• #40

What we are forgetting now is that we are a Run Of the Mill championship club , so attracting the best will be hard to secure especially as we dont or wont pay top dollar. We now have the problem of attracting the best and this is down to CH to do . At least with Poyet we had that chance , but cannot see it under the present regime , hence signing Mcshane and Zamora etc would be good if they could pull it off