Grombleton
Surrounded by <div>s
- Dec 31, 2011
- 7,356
Did Stockdale get booked? I didn't see him get a card and there's nothing on the BBC site suggesting so. I figured he may do eventually but can't recall.
Got something to say or just want fewer pesky ads? Join us... 😊
Last night's ref
- Thread starter Gwylan
- Start date
Did Stockdale get booked? I didn't see him get a card and there's nothing on the BBC site suggesting so. I figured he may do eventually but can't recall.
I had this explained to me is some detail by a former referee regarding handball. Basically it is ball to hand is not an offence but hand to ball is, and the only ones I saw which did not result in a free kick were the former.
The Hon Sec
New member
Our old chairman used to ref for us occasionally and he often used the phrase 'ball to hand'. In his later life, still refereeing when we were desperate, he often said the same thing whether he saw the incident or not. It was usually the latter. Still brings a smile now to those who were around then.
I must have missed that... although he was pushing it to the limit in the 2nd half... I thought he went unpunished??
Withdean11
Well-known member
Fair enough. But surely if it stops play it should be given as a foul? If it's 'ball to hand' that blocks the ball going in the net it has to be a penalty?
LamieRobertson
Not awoke
I
Agree re the assistant in the east side
Re Stockdale getting booked ..a rare moment for us to pick up a card for time wasting at the Amex this season ..and truly savoured
Agree re the assistant in the east side
Re Stockdale getting booked ..a rare moment for us to pick up a card for time wasting at the Amex this season ..and truly savoured
I remember a couple of claims for handballs where it hit players in the chest. I remember one where the ball was whacked at a player one foot away whose hands were down at his side, and I remember one where the Ipswich player's arm was sticking out, probably had time to react, definitely gained an advantage, but was perhaps the wrong side of the ref for him to see it clearly.
I thought he was a little inconsistent with his judgement of how much force was needed to constitute a foul, and whether or not jumping on someone's back was a foul.
I thought he was a little inconsistent with his judgement of how much force was needed to constitute a foul, and whether or not jumping on someone's back was a foul.
How I felt. Thought he was inconsistent. Free-kicks taken from the 'incorrect place' - by 3 yards, then allowed exactly the same thing several other times.
Best ref for me this season was Charlton away.
SIMMO SAYS
Well-known member
Should have booked Stockdale for time wasting in the first minute
mikevapour
New member
- Apr 18, 2012
- 26
First time Stroud has been ok, still can't understand why he was the ref at Bournemouth earlier in the season when he is from Bournemouth
