I think time is up for CMS and I fully expect him to be sold in January if we get any interest whatsoever. I really wanted him to be a success and think he is a top bloke and I have never seen a player try so hard. Very sad for him as he as never been used to his strenghts at Brighton. I would be amazed if we offer him a new deal as we have Baldock to do exactly what CMS does. Bye Craig and thanks for trying.
Got something to say or just want fewer pesky ads? Join us... 😊
Craig Mackail- Smith
- Thread starter Neecha
- Start date
22.5K a week according to Matt Sparrows dad in the gents at Millwall about 3 years ago......
Marshy
Well-known member
Im not convinced its quite that much, if it is then he will run his deal down before going anywhere !
durrington gull
Well-known member
Spot on - time to move him on
kevtherev
Well-known member
Well all know he is going to move on. Get a manager who plays him up front with a big partner and he will score a shed load of goals.
I wouldn't surprised if his confidence is shot to pieces. 3.5 years of playing in a team with zero interest in helping you score after 2 years at Posh where the opposite was true must have really knocked him back and add in his injury.
As others have said, I see the same future unfolding for Baldock at the moment: both excellent strikers being asked to play a different way for the team, diminishing their contribution.
What truly baffles me is this: WHY DOES NOBODY LOOK AT DEFENDERS IN THIS LEAGUE? They're all 6' 5" monsters and we keep signing 5' 8" strikers and either play them alone against them or sling them on the wing. Who decides these strategies?!
As others have said, I see the same future unfolding for Baldock at the moment: both excellent strikers being asked to play a different way for the team, diminishing their contribution.
What truly baffles me is this: WHY DOES NOBODY LOOK AT DEFENDERS IN THIS LEAGUE? They're all 6' 5" monsters and we keep signing 5' 8" strikers and either play them alone against them or sling them on the wing. Who decides these strategies?!
Bish Bosh
Active member
That's an argument for the diminutive striker as well though. Play them in so they can slide past the 6' 5" monsters.
Thing is we are hardly ever providing that kind of service.
Justice
Dangerous Idiot
BHAFC the club that ruins 30 goals a season strikers.
durrington gull
Well-known member
Not in the championship will he score though - good league 1 plyr
Caveman
Well-known member
- Jul 14, 2003
- 9,926
If someone shows interest then surely we will take the money and reduce the wage bill. If cms is prepared to extend on a new deal then I'd be happy. I keep hoping he will hit form as he is a definate confidence striker. With the lack of support and injury hasn't helped.
carteater
Well-known member
this is a human being you're talking about, not an inanimate object.
Uncle C
Well-known member
When will you be putting your money into the club?
crodonilson
He/Him
How much would we get for him? I think we'd be struggling to get a seven figure sum for him. Needs a spell on loan jnL1 to rediscover his goalscoring touch and confidence.
Hastings gull
Well-known member
- Nov 23, 2013
- 4,635
I recall in the good old days how pleased I was when defences had these monsters, when Peter Ward was so much faster, and then earned us no end of penalties, even before the days of regular diving! Watching Baldock on his won against Blackburn struggle yet again to get to long hoofs when he did not have chance, was quite depressing. The original Op was right -all the teams seem to have big defenders, as we have, so why oh why is poor old SB stuck on his own to get on the end of high balls?
Returning to the thread, I to have become quite disillusioned with CSM after initial enthusiasm with his record prior to coming here -it really cannot be said that it has worked out, though I am sure that the many posts here saying that we do not play to his strengths are valid.
carteater
Well-known member
I feel bad for him in the fact that he came here with over 30 goals in a season to his name, and then because we played a style that didn't suit him he hasn't lived up to lots of people's too high expectations, Im sure he also wasn't helped by the pressure of being the club's record signing.
Smythe
Active member
Exactly this, the club have again bought a good league 1 striker in Baldock with a good scoring record at that level but needs to play as part of a front 2. So we have 4.5million worth of strikers in CMS and Baldock but have never played to either of their strengths so they have both struggled at championship level.
chucky1973
New member
Our record of signing strikers ulloa aside is just shocking. I would keep as the chances of replacing with anything that will give half as much effort is so small. keep and sign some else. 3 strikers one out and one in is not enough for this league
portslade seagull
Well-known member
Makes you wish Vicente was still here to put the balls through
GoldWithFalmer
Seaweed! Seaweed!
I would be inclined to sell,him and Ulloa would have been a good partnership but it was not to be..
We have a habit of getting strikers that have done ok and then they come here and don't perform subsequently they move on and do ok again and i don't just mean when we have been in the Championship..
We have never got world beating forward players but there have been quite a few and i am at a loss as to whether it is coaching,tactics,pressure of playing for this club,the distractions that Brighton can offer a player outside of the game,i just don't know,but when they come here things just do not seem to click..
Sell and good luck CMS,sorry it did not really work out here as it could have had.
We have a habit of getting strikers that have done ok and then they come here and don't perform subsequently they move on and do ok again and i don't just mean when we have been in the Championship..
We have never got world beating forward players but there have been quite a few and i am at a loss as to whether it is coaching,tactics,pressure of playing for this club,the distractions that Brighton can offer a player outside of the game,i just don't know,but when they come here things just do not seem to click..
Sell and good luck CMS,sorry it did not really work out here as it could have had.