Player ratings- Charlton (A)

stss30 · Dec 8, 2012

Kuszczak-8-Couldn't do anything about the goals, kicking was better, can only remember one occasion where it went straight out of play
Bruno-7-Decent
Greer-6.5-Beaten in the air too much and a few aimless balls at times
El-Abd-8-Made some key clearances, good to have him back
Bridge-7-Bit quiter than usual but good to have him back
Bridcutt-9(MOTM)-Immense
Hammond-8.5-Best game this season IMO
Buckley-7-Lacked end product and looked a bit tired in the 2nd half
Dobbie-5-Very poor
Hoskins-7.5-Chased everything, played the Barnes role with much more energy
CMS-9-Very good link up play today and a superbly taken goal, very good

Subs:Barnes-7-Decent
LuaLua-8-Showed some great touches, if he works on his fitness I think he could be key for us
Calderon-7-Good attacking play, little end product

nomoremithras4me · Dec 8, 2012

stss30 said:
Kuszczak-8-Couldn't do anything about the goals, kicking was better, can only remember one occasion where it went straight out of play
Bruno-7-Decent
Greer-6.5-Beaten in the air too much and a few aimless balls at times
El-Abd-8-Made some key clearances, good to have him back
Bridge-7-Bit quiter than usual but good to have him back
Bridcutt-9(MOTM)-Immense
Hammond-8.5-Best game this season IMO
Buckley-7-Lacked end product and looked a bit tired in the 2nd half
Dobbie-5-Very poor
Hoskins-7.5-Chased everything, played the Barnes role with much more energy
CMS-9-Very good link up play today and a superbly taken goal, very good

Subs:Barnes-7-Decent
LuaLua-8-Showed some great touches, if he works on his fitness I think he could be key for us
Calderon-7-Good attacking play, little end product

Very fair assessment, wouldn't disagree with any of your comments

stss30 · Dec 8, 2012

nomoremithras4me said:
Very fair assessment, wouldn't disagree with any of your comments

There's a first time for everything :thumbsup:

One Teddy Maybank · Dec 8, 2012

Kuszczak 6
Bruno 7
Bridge 7
Greer 5 - was poor for me and never seems to attack the ball
AEA 7
Hammond 8 - MoM
Buckley 7.5
Bridcutt 8
Dobbie 5 - was pleased when we signed him, but form wise is very disappointing
Hoskins 6 - worked hard
CMS 8

Calderon 6
Barnes 7 - good touches, we had more presence physically when he replaced Dobbie.
KLL 7 - on fire...... Needs games

Support - outstanding effort everyone.

Mellotron · Dec 8, 2012

Would go along with everything so far except mark up Buckley a bit - caused them endless problems.

GingerBeerMan · Dec 8, 2012

One Teddy Maybank said:
KLL 7 - on fire...... Needs games

On fire? You can tell this from a 20 minute cameo?

tweenster · Dec 8, 2012

Are we likely to see Hoskins starting more often in place of Barnes? I hope so.

Kneon Light · Dec 8, 2012

tweenster said:
Are we likely to see Hoskins starting more often in place of Barnes? I hope so.

Given todays performances I would start both of them and not Dobbie.
Barnes looked very good in the attacking midfield role when he came on.

One Teddy Maybank · Dec 8, 2012

Mellotron said:
Would go along with everything so far except mark up Buckley a bit - caused them endless problems.

You are probably right, I gave him 7, really as I think his delivery latterly was poor. Have amended to 7.5

stss30 · Dec 8, 2012

Mellotron said:
Would go along with everything so far except mark up Buckley a bit - caused them endless problems.

I thought he looked weak in the 2nd half although admittedly he is always one of our best players so maybe I'm being too critical of him. Missed a good chance in the 2nd half, but with him and LuaLua on both fully fit we'll be a force to be reckoned with imo.

One Teddy Maybank · Dec 8, 2012

GingerBeerMan said:
On fire? You can tell this from a 20 minute cameo?

Yes. He was very similar to when he came on and destroyed them 2 years ago. Did you go?

stss30 · Dec 8, 2012

Kneon Light said:
Given todays performances I would start both of them and not Dobbie.
Barnes looked very good in the attacking midfield role when he came on.

Agreed. Barnes is better the more attacking position he is in, he wins headers and free kicks in good areas.

One Teddy Maybank · Dec 8, 2012

Kneon Light said:
Given todays performances I would start both of them and not Dobbie.
Barnes looked very good in the attacking midfield role when he came on.

Exactly what we said on way back.

stss30 · Dec 8, 2012

One Teddy Maybank said:
Yes. He was very similar to when he came on and destroyed them 2 years ago. Did you go?

Agreed btw. Thought he looked a live wire and was well up for it. Good to see.

GingerBeerMan · Dec 8, 2012

One Teddy Maybank said:
Yes. He was very similar to when he came on and destroyed them 2 years ago. Did you go?

"On Fire" suggests a sustained period of good form, hence my initial confusion at your statement.

Chesney Christ · Dec 8, 2012

Bridcutt was absolutely different class today. Clear MOM.

Dobbie was an absolute joke. Seems completely uninterested.

One Teddy Maybank · Dec 8, 2012

GingerBeerMan said:
"On Fire" suggests a sustained period of good form, hence my initial confusion at your statement.

Sorry, I don't agree re sustainability.....

Rugrat · Dec 8, 2012

Star performances from Bridcutt, Hammond and KLL (for his time on)

Most of the rest put in a great shift

Dobbie bringing up the rear

I reckon Bridcutt will be Captain next year ... Gus defo does all the talking to him and he's so calm and assured ... we'd really struggle without him

u'vebeenamexed · Dec 8, 2012

Couldn't make the game today - had to listen on radio.

I'll give our fans 10/10 - great effort today everyone that went :clap:

BUTTERBALL · Dec 8, 2012

They said on the radio when Dobbie came off there was no acknowledgement, no handshake, pat on the back etc. Was Gus hacked off with his performance?

Got something to say or just want fewer pesky ads? Join us... 😊

Player ratings- Charlton (A)

Registered User

Active member

Registered User

Well-known member

I've asked for soup

3-0

New member

Well-known member

Well-known member

Registered User

Well-known member

Registered User

Well-known member

Registered User

3-0

New member

Well-known member

Well-known member

Whateverhappenedto.......

East Stand Brighton Boyz

Share this page