On that basis, you don't think there was anything wrong with the holocaust or the Srebrenica Massacre or what went on in Rwanda. Afterall, there was a war going on so anything goes!
I used the phrase 'in effect' in anticipation that a host of blood lusty posters would point out that the Taliban aren't signed up to the Geneva convention! I would also presume that before moving him, he was search for weapons as not to do so would have been dumb.
He was in effect a prisoner of war at the time he was murdered. We don't arbitrarily execute prisoners of war. I fail to see why some people can't get their head around that principle! Perhaps it is the ignorance of mob mentality!
I can't work out whether you are just a wind up merchant or...
Can't believe anyone can claim it was anything other than murder. The Afghan was, at the time, unarmed, injured and posing no immediate threat. The dialogue seems to suggest Marine A knew what he was doing and acknowledged the criminality with his comment relating to the Geneva convention...