Actually I’m confused - sounds like you think there are good and bad presenters, male and female, some of which have played the game to a high standard , some of which haven’t. In which case agreed.
Do you listen to radio Sussex ? Johnny Cantor is one of the best pundit/ commentators about. On premier league football. Hasn’t played football to even county league standard afaik or the football ramble podcast guys or Henry winter or Paul Hayward - and most national football journalists. Yet...