He was great for us as a lower-mid PL team, but we started getting better and he didn't. Don't understand this need for some of our fans to write him off completely - he scored some very important goals for us and always tried hard.
I'm a bit sad for him that it's gone so badly at Everton, but...
Conversely, I would have liked to have seen him under RDZ. I think he has a similar problem to what March had in terms of confidence in front of goal, and if that had been sorted he would have been a great striker for us.
Everton was always a bad move for him though