But the difference is BZ is old and Elliott is still young, and actually played well in the premier league, so clearly had the ability to play at that level.
In terms of the injury cruciate repairs seem two a penny these days, and Shearer and Keane even 10 years ago, proved you can come back at...
I seem to recall he did well in the premier league as well.
Given that you are normally quite measured, I really don't understand your problem and am surprised you are basing any argument on a loan deal, that was largely to help him with his fitness. I seem to recall he played well at Fulham in...