Got something to say or just want fewer pesky ads? Join us... 😊

Search results

  1. Mellotron

    Disallowed penalty/goal for Newcastle last night...

    For me it was way too open to interpretation to rescind the red. To rescind you have to be 100,000% sure Shelvey meant no malice whatsoever towards Lansbury in the untangling/kicking out/loosening of legs. No one could blame Shelvey for having malice towards Lansbury, because Lansbury is an...
  2. Mellotron

    Disallowed penalty/goal for Newcastle last night...

    Here you are correct. No one is suggesting video tech will suddenly solve all the world's ills. But if it leads to a higher % of right calls, then obviously that's a good thing. If anything, it also dispels the silly myth that we'd have nothing to discuss and debate - an argument rendered even...
  3. Mellotron

    Disallowed penalty/goal for Newcastle last night...

    Whether there was contact or not is irrelevant. It's about the intent. He kicked out, as you say. Debate kinda ends there.
  4. Mellotron

    Disallowed penalty/goal for Newcastle last night...

    The Forests reds were both rescinded, even though Shelvey clearly tries to kick the guy?! If anything that shows bias towards Toon! The other one (Dummett) was a slightly harsh red, as although it was unquestionably last man Lansbury definitely made a meal of it. You're also forgetting that...
Albion and Premier League latest from Sky Sports


Top
Link Here