I was impressed with Crofts. The bloke has been through a lot recently with his injuries but came in and did a solid job yesterday. Stephens and Kayal were pretty much untouchable so it's great that they will now have a bit of competition. A fit Crofts playing alongside those two in a midfield...
Reading have some fairly capable forwards, I'd want my defence to be as strong as possible. Rosenior has played left back many times for Hull in the PL, yes we'd lose him down the right but we can cover that adequately with other players. Calderon would be weaker at left back than Rosenior...