He also made the most posts in the year. I suspect some more detailed (but not much more detailed) analysis of thumbs v post volume would reveal more. I can't be arsed to do it though.
The most thumbsed-down post of the year wanted us to lose at Burton Albion - http://www.northstandchat.com/showthread.php?309566-I-really-hope-Burton-beat-Brighton-tomorrow-night-Reason-Inside&p=6582773&viewfull=1#post6582773
The most thumbs-upped post of the year was about Chris O'Grady. Of course - http://www.northstandchat.com/showthread.php?305206-COG-The-BFC-lowdown-(as-promised)&p=6456870&viewfull=1#post6456870
These people received the most thumbs down in 2014...
L2MidgetGem B.H.A Seagull
357
BensGrandad
329
sir albion
248
Ernest
242
Mustafa
218
Skylar
209
Tubby-McFat-Fuc
175
TaxiRichieUK
171
brightonmark1234
143
carteater
127
Kosh
121
Steve Foster
117
jcdenton08
116
Phat...
These people received the most thumbs up in 2014...
hans kraay fan club
1786
Tom Hark, Preston Park
1312
Bozza
1308
edna krabappel
1263
Ernest
1255
Stat Brother
1074
Mustafa
1036
El Presidente
969
Icy Gull
924
Hillian1
855
Buzzer
832
8ace
808
Thunder Bolt
794...
The top 100 thumbs-downers...
Husty
399
Mustafa
344
Notters
341
Rod Marsh
296
TSB
278
hans kraay fan club
234
brightonmark1234
226
mona
188
GingerBeerMan
186
Trust in Tony
177
GT49er
158
wilko1
156
HawkTheSeagull
153
Mowgli37
147
The Large One
145
Felpham Seagull...
The top 100 thumbers...
Notters
4291
aolstudios
2473
Thunder Bolt
2364
hans kraay fan club
2362
DarrenFreemansPerm
2174
Mowgli37
1953
GT49er
1827
TSB
1613
Tom Hark, Preston Park
1561
seagully
1521
bn9 bha
1410
Rod Marsh
1387
Mellotron
1380
spring hall convert
1287...