Kayal was taken off injured v Hull and hadn't completely recovered. Not sure why he was on the bench, surely being 3-0 down inside the first half would make you think 'things are bad enough to risk him'. So I think we have to allow for that change.
The only possible argument I can think of for...
You seemed to stop halfway through your list of 'how many points we'd have if...' scenarios. To be honest, I'm not entirely sure what point you were trying to make, but I thought I'd be helpful and finish the list anyway.
I'd like to think not, but people criticised Stockdale's kicking v Brentford. Someone felt that Stockdale's kicking is so perfect, he must have been under instruction to kick it out of play, or straight through to their keeper in that game. So, maybe he did?
But more seriously, he decided to...
If we lose on Tuesday, we'll have 0 points.
If we'd drawn today, and win on Tuesday, we'd have four points.
If we'd won today, and we win on Tuesday, we'd have 6 points.
Well, we started the game well, maintaining most of the possession and attacking for the first 10 mins or so, but couldn't convert that into a decent chance on goal. When Cardiff attacked, our defence backed off and backed off, sidwell lost his man, and Cardiff toe poked the ball in from 12...
For the third goal, looking at the replay Dunk is running to the edge of the six yard box behind Goldson too soon, perhaps anticipating the guy beating Goldson, that left a gaping hole for the Cardiff player who collected that lucky bounce.
I don't know that the overall performance is the same, but the elements that are being criticised absolutely have been there all season. There has been a element of luck, or maybe destiny, with opposition wasting the great chances they are gifted from our 'back off, back off, back off' defence...
A lot of what is being criticised are things that I've seen in most of our home games this season - defenders backing off and backing off, no movement up front (or on set pieces), not doing enough with our attacks (our goals tend to be counter attacks these days, catching the defence out, when...