Your 'pointing out' is the cynical bit because all you are doing is 'pointing out' a scenario that is a pure guess on your part. It is an opinion you hold based on no evidence.
If you can provide the evidence then I will apologetically agree with you!
You doubt it because you have knowledge of the facts to justify your doubts? Or you doubt it simply because you want to?
And you want another thread to debate it so you can continue to criticise the club? Are you in possession of all the facts to 'analyse' it?