Its all about opinions I guess. I personally think he is too slow for the prem and doesnt hold the ball up well enough for a chap of his size. I am sure though in his defence he is carrying an injury as he has barely jumped since his return. As you say we shall see.
Really - I dont think he is. Since his injury he has been a shadow of his former self. I would definitey take 6.5 million for him assuming all the cash would be reinvested in the team.