[Football] FA Cup quarter-finals

birthofanorange · Mar 17, 2024

jcdenton08 said:
But then you’re asking the referee to assess the occasion and personal meaning of each individual instance where it happens. Someone’s birthday? A memorial message? Happy anniversary to the wife?

Referees can’t be expected to know or assess what is an “acceptable” reason - hence the blanket ban. And it’s not like it’s a new rule.I realise that,

jcdenton08 said:
But then you’re asking the referee to assess the occasion and personal meaning of each individual instance where it happens. Someone’s birthday? A memorial message? Happy anniversary to the wife?

Referees can’t be expected to know or assess what is an “acceptable” reason - hence the blanket ban. And it’s not like it’s a new rule.

I realise that, yes, but it still seems a pointless thing to do, at that late stage. I guess I've always been an advocate of the 'rules are there to be broken'.
Maybe that's why I've spent too many years 'inside'.

(I really haven't, in case you believe it.

)

oldboyroy · Mar 17, 2024

PILTDOWN MAN said:
You forgot the stroppy one

God yes, forgot all about him!

jcdenton08 · Mar 17, 2024

A1X said:

That is liquid commentary, it really is great banter

Harry Wilson's tackle · Mar 17, 2024

Have any helpful cognoscenti popped onto this thread to announce they "don't give a shit about the FA cup" yet?

Hopefully they would be part of my Ignored Portfolio (which I am prepared to franchise out, for a small consideration).

Bodian · Mar 17, 2024

So, if we'd got through, it would have been 'you've seen Utd, now f*ck off home' for us all over again.....

Jeremiah · Mar 17, 2024

One lower league side left in the cup and Man U draw them. Hot balls !

studio150 · Mar 17, 2024

Justice said:
I agree with you and I could stomach it if the refs are consistent does Haaland get the second yellow for shirt removal I’m not so sure.

I on the other hand am certain that if Haaland is stupid enough to take his shirt off, it will get a yellow, and a red if its his second yellow of the game.

The ref may well give a shrug of his shoulders, as clearly he has no latitude, but Haaland will be walking off.

Wardy's twin · Mar 17, 2024

I didn't watch much and switched off as spoon as MUFC scored the 4th to have a quick prayer that it went to VAR and was disallowed and Liverpool then won on penalties....

Guinness Boy · Mar 17, 2024

A1X said:
I know, but the rule is ridiculous

Yes this. Said immediately he took his shirt off that he was gone. However, in what world do you have to leave the field after a bit of gamesmanship and then celebrating an absolutely iconic goal but not when you full on assault Pascal Gross while playing for Fulham?

BNthree · Mar 17, 2024

Harry Wilson's tackle said:
Have any helpful cognoscenti popped onto this thread to announce they "don't give a shit about the FA cup" yet?

Hopefully they would be part of my Ignored Portfolio (which I am prepared to franchise out, for a small consideration).

Nope, seems everyone so far has been enjoying this round and saying how entertaining the matches have been.

oldboyroy · Mar 17, 2024

fly high said:
True but you have to feel for the young lad, just didn't think, could see him tapping his head as he walked down the tunnel.

Bry Nylon · Mar 17, 2024

Wardy's twin said:
I didn't watch much and switched off as spoon as MUFC scored the 4th to have a quick prayer that it went to VAR and was disallowed and Liverpool then won on penalties....

Christ no

Thank God Liverpool have ben knocked out; it would have been unbearable had they ultimately reached the Final. Klopp's only been there 7 years but the media narrative would have ben unrelentingly all about him and the FA KLOPP Final etc.

Bodian · Mar 17, 2024

Bry Nylon said:
Christ no

Thank God Liverpool have ben knocked out; it would have been unbearable had they ultimately reached the Final. Klopp's only been there 7 years but the media narrative would have ben unrelentingly all about him and the FA KLOPP Final etc.

Yes - but instead we're going to have to put up (probably) with all the Manchester Derby bollocks that we had last year - and how wonderful it is.

kevo · Mar 17, 2024

Bodian said:
Yes - but instead we're going to have to put up (probably) with all the Manchester Derby bollocks that we had last year - and how wonderful it is.

Which is still preferable to Chelsea getting there.

BN41Albion · Mar 17, 2024

Goodie another United - City final for City to win

Hugo Rune · Mar 17, 2024

El Turi said:
Dewsbury-Hall is looking very good. I think there will be a lot of competition for his signature in the summer.

Leicester will keep him if they can get through June without selling due to FFP issues but I strongly suspect they’ll have to (unless they can convince other clubs to take other players).

In which case, what teams (other than us) are likely to sign him? By all accounts, the majority of our competition will have their own FFP challenges to deal with in June, perhaps KDH won’t be a concern?

Eeyore · Mar 18, 2024

Looks like it could be the first ever repeat of a Wembley cup final. I don't think it's happened in the last 100 years or so.

Kalimantan Gull · Mar 18, 2024

Eeyore said:
Looks like it could be the first ever repeat of a Wembley cup final. I don't think it's happened in the last 100 years or so.

Which is why I think Chelsea will beat City

Justice · Mar 18, 2024

Hugo Rune said:
Leicester will keep him if they can get through June without selling due to FFP issues but I strongly suspect they’ll have to (unless they can convince other clubs to take other players).

In which case, what teams (other than us) are likely to sign him? By all accounts, the majority of our competition will have their own FFP challenges to deal with in June, perhaps KDH won’t be a concern?

He is the perfect Mac replacement with some added pace. Our season could have been different if we had signed him in January..

Got something to say or just want fewer pesky ads? Join us... 😊

[Football] FA Cup quarter-finals

Well-known member

Well-known member

Well-known member

Enemy of the People

Harry Wilson's Tackle

Well-known member

God is great

Well-known member

Well-known member

Tofu eating wokerati

Plastic JCL

Well-known member

Test your smoke alarm

Well-known member

Well-known member

Well-known member

Well-known member

Colonel Hee-Haw of Queen's Park

Well-known member

Dangerous Idiot

Share this page