Bold Seagull
strong and stable with me, or...
Amazing how clear the view is 100m away in the North Stand. Maybe it needs to be renamed the Specsavers End.
Got something to say or just want fewer pesky ads? Join us... 😊
[Albion] That was a red wasn’t it?
- Thread starter Herr Tubthumper
- Start date
Have any of these refs even played the game at Sunday league or youth level when they were kids. Do they understand how tackles work. Are players supposed to be robots now.
London Irish
Well-known member
Don’t say VAR never gives us any breaks 
pb21
Well-known member
- Apr 23, 2010
- 6,330
Apparently do what you like as long as you get the ball first
It's encouraging to see that over 70% didn't view that through Albion-tinted glasses.
Yes, we've seen worse against us not given (as a red), but there really is no doubt that Moder should have been given his marching orders.
Sometimes....just sometimes...things actually do go in our favour.
Yes, we've seen worse against us not given (as a red), but there really is no doubt that Moder should have been given his marching orders.
Sometimes....just sometimes...things actually do go in our favour.
As others have said, the fact that it was low probably saved him. However if the Ref saw red, VAR wouldn't have overturned it - mad isn't it? The problem is consistency unless you go to a micro level i.e below the ankle = yellow or above the ankle = red, which obviously isn't going to happen.
I can see why they stayed with yellow, but also understand from a consistency perspective if they went red. I can also sympathise with Notts Forest.....
I can see why they stayed with yellow, but also understand from a consistency perspective if they went red. I can also sympathise with Notts Forest.....
It seemed fairly clearcut at the time and nothing I've seen since suggests otherwise.
As with many such decisions the only mitigation I'll give it is the challenge looked increasingly worse the slower it got.
As with many such decisions the only mitigation I'll give it is the challenge looked increasingly worse the slower it got.
A definite orange in my book. Wouldn’t have complained if it was a red but in real time thought it was a yellow.
I also thought their Nr 6 should have got a second yellow for simulation when Lallana bumped him in the last few minutes.
I also thought their Nr 6 should have got a second yellow for simulation when Lallana bumped him in the last few minutes.
Gabbiano
Well-known member
It really should have been a red, very dangerous.
If the Forest player had his weight planted on that foot it would have shattered his ankle.
If the Forest player had his weight planted on that foot it would have shattered his ankle.
portslade seagull
Well-known member
One of the Forest commentary team behind us in WSU went mad when a red wasn't given. Received a bit of grief from surrounding fans
studio150
Well-known member
The weekend that Gilmour got his red, there was a lengthy debate about the Harry Maguire challenge that only received a yellow (leaving aside the usual top 6 bias) the consensus was that Maguire only deserved a yellow due to the fact that the impact was lower than Gilmour's.
Therefore for consistency Moder deserves no more than the yellow that was given.
At the ground, I was fully expecting the ref to be sent to the TV screen to review his decision once it went to VAR.
Therefore for consistency Moder deserves no more than the yellow that was given.
At the ground, I was fully expecting the ref to be sent to the TV screen to review his decision once it went to VAR.
pasty
A different kind of pasty
Ah, so that was what happened
I was wondering
Having see the replay, was amazed VAR didn’t give it.
Knew he was in trouble as soon as he’d made one challenge then dived in for the second, it never looks good.
Knew he was in trouble as soon as he’d made one challenge then dived in for the second, it never looks good.
On the pitch, it was exactly how it should’ve been dealt with in the modern game. Salisbury calmed everyone down, took his time, and decided not to make a hard decision and put VAR in a corner where it had to produce irrefutable evidence it was NOT a red to overturn it.
Personally, I think that there was enough evidence for Pawson to overturn the decision on VAR and send Moder off, I’m surprised (and glad) that he didn’t.
Personally, I think that there was enough evidence for Pawson to overturn the decision on VAR and send Moder off, I’m surprised (and glad) that he didn’t.
Greg Bobkin
Silver Seagull
- May 22, 2012
- 14,860
This is the problem with VAR/officiating football these days. Sometimes it would be a red, sometimes (Like today) it wouldn't be.
So, was it? Who knows?!
So, was it? Who knows?!