Seagull58
In the Algarve
The law states "the probability of a comparison involving Nazis or Hitler approaches 1."
The post to which I responded referenced WWII and Jewish refugees fleeing to the UK. Hence fulfilling Godwin's Law
[News] Major incident in Newhaven
- Thread starter TomandJerry
- Start date
Got something to say or just want fewer pesky ads? Join us... 😊
The post to which I responded referenced WWII and Jewish refugees fleeing to the UK. Hence fulfilling Godwin's Law
- Oct 20, 2022
- 4,951
Yes it is but that shouldn’t be mutually exclusive to your first point I quoted - we don’t know anything about the 6 people seeking asylum (they don’t get refugee status until they are ’processed’ btw.) - no one can assume at this stage whether they are in fear of their lives in their country of origin and needing assistance (well obviously they need some assistance as they arrived in a locked freezer then taken to hospital but I mean needing refugee status) - which takes time for the authorities to determine.
Again, no one arrives ‘illegally’ if they are seeking asylum. The 6 hiding in the freezer were not ‘illegal’ because they arrived without papers and didn’t go through border control - ie one can presume they will all be seeking asylum - those crossing the channel in boats and lorries have paid smugglers (who are the criminals in this scenario), often what amounts to their entire life savings to seek asylum in the UK. I think it would be presumptuous to assume they had the money to pay so are less needy of asylum than others. We don’t know anything about them at this stage. But yes, there are millions of displaced people in war torn Countries/or where civil war has made them targets, who do not have the means to pay people-smugglers. It is even more criminal when you realise how little the smugglers do to ensure their physical safety. We need to open up some safe routes as a matter of priority IMO.
But just to reiterate, those arriving in the UK seeking asylum are a very small minority in comparison to the total net immigration. In fact the annual figure is just under the maximum capacity of Old Trafford.
Top facts from the latest statistics on refugees and people seeking asylum
Here are our top facts based on the UK Government's latest immigration statistics for the year ending September 2023.
www.refugeecouncil.org.uk
We need to open up some safe routes as a matter of priority IMO.
- Aug 24, 2020
- 5,446
Weak. I think your use of Godwin's law is tenuous to say the least, given Clampy didn't actually reference Hitler or the Nazis at all. I'm being kind here.
- Oct 20, 2022
- 4,951
Some of the comments on this thread puts a whole new spin on the validity of ‘Darwenism’
- Aug 24, 2020
- 5,446
Did you know that the locals of Darwen pronounce it as 'Darren'?Some of the comments on this thread puts a whole new spin on the validity of ‘Darwenism’
Not a lot of people know that, unless you live around there, or are married to a woman from Accrington.
This has nothing to do with the thread title, but the horse has kind of bolted and is standing in a field in another county.
Your posts are right on point however.
Seagull58
In the Algarve
A comparison "involving" Hitler and the Nazis, not "referencing" Hitler and the Nazis. I'd say that a comparison referencing Jewish refugees in WWII certainly involves Hitler and the Nazis, wouldn't you?
As a follow up to my last post I’m still not feeling threatened by immigrants. Maybe @cunning fergus needs to up his game?
LamieRobertson
Not awoke
After a quick google I see one person has been charged after two were arrested ….no update on those taken to hospital…but on a positive note they’ve confirmed no one has died. Facts as I understand them unless anyone has anything to counter that.
beorhthelm
A. Virgo, Football Genius
- Jul 21, 2003
- 35,365
nowt to do with integration. if they're coming from certain Islamic countries, claim asylum on religious grounds they can't be return as it'll be unsafe for them.
- Aug 24, 2020
- 5,446
It is matter of interpretation. Mine differs from yours. For instance, the gravamen of Godwin's law is a comparison of Nazis and Hitler, the cause of the Holocaust. The comparison by @The Clamp referenced Jewish refugees (a manifestation of the Holocaust) and WW2 (the war in which it occurred). Sure they are linked, but do you see that they are not the same thing? At the risk of repeating myself, it was you who used the terms Nazis and Hitler, and nobody else. You then used Godwin's Law against @The Clamp. You tried to mock him.
But nobody joined you in your 'laughter' on post #205.
All this on a thread about six desperate individuals who risked their lives, confined in a small space, damaged the motor to save their lives, gassed themselves, and are now hospitalised. They could have died.
beorhthelm
A. Virgo, Football Genius
- Jul 21, 2003
- 35,365
if i were seeking asylum i'd go to Germany too, much more supportive. does make one wonder why go to the extra risk of crossing the channel.
clivebuckley
New member
- Jul 28, 2011
- 18
Nice way of saying what you ready think, unbelievable it hardly Warrents a comment.
Padden?
Eh?
You don’t get asylum because you’ve BECOME something. You get it because you had good reason to leave in the first place,
beorhthelm
A. Virgo, Football Genius
- Jul 21, 2003
- 35,365
how do you prove you're at risk? demostrate your religion through recognised conversion and all good.
Jeez, I should be shocked that a thread like this has brought them out of the woodwork, but I'm not.
Perhaps we should rename it "Bozza"
Maybe they speak English but not German.
The weird thing is, I've read that locals pronounce it Darren, but none of the people I've met from there actually do.
This annoys me far more than it should do.
TomandJerry
Well-known member
- Oct 1, 2013
- 11,692
- Thread starter
- #260
Seems to be about the sum of the story so far