Got something to say or just want fewer pesky ads? Join us... 😊

General Election 2015



glasfryn

cleaning up cat sick
Nov 29, 2005
20,261
somewhere in Eastbourne
The paradox being that Labour needs its Scottish MPs to form a majority. However the rise of the SNP will obliterate Labour in Scotland and **** up their chances of froming the next government. I reckon the net result of the rise of the SNP will be Cameron back in No 10.

the SNP have already said they will vote against the tories if they get to power, they will be a bit like labour only further to the left
 






Bry Nylon

Test your smoke alarm
Helpful Moderator
Jul 21, 2003
19,891
Playing snooker
Can you please explain how this is the case. The Tories currently have one MP. They'll be lucky to keep that one I suspect, but they're not going to be gaining any seats, so how will it result in getting Cameron back into No 10? It's more likely to lead to a minority government or another Coalition, with Labour in charge.

the SNP have already said they will vote against the tories if they get to power, they will be a bit like labour only further to the left

The point I was making is that the SNP are currently on course to take anything between 28 - 35 seats from Labour in Scotland. These are seats that Labour strategists would have relied upon when calculating their expected total. They are now going to have to find another 30 or seats in England and Wales that they believe they can take form the Tories just to counter-act the ones they are going to lose in Scotland.
The paradox is that every seat the SNP win simply makes Labour's task of forming the next government harder. This is why Tories have been so fulsome in their praise of Nicola Sturgeon since Thursday's Leaders' debate.
 


seagullsovergrimsby

#cpfctinpotclub
Aug 21, 2005
43,690
Crap Town
Latest poll out , this is from Opinium/Observer

Con 33%
Lab 33%
UKIP 14%
Green 7%
LD 7%
 


Bry Nylon

Test your smoke alarm
Helpful Moderator
Jul 21, 2003
19,891
Playing snooker
From Survation:

Ed Miliband will fail to lead his party to an outright majority at the election because of the rise of the SNP.
A Daily Record/ Survation poll found that the SNP is set to win 47 seats in Scotland and Labour just 10 as almost half of Scots vote for Nicola Sturgeon's party.
Damian Lyons Lowe, chief executive of Survation, said that the results "could cost Ed Miliband the chance of a small workable majority in May".
He said that the results would leave Labour 31 seats short of the 321 seats it needs to win a majority in Westminster. If the SNP succeed in taking 21 seats from Labour another Conservative/ Liberal Democrat Coalition is the likely result.
 




Machiavelli

Well-known member
Oct 11, 2013
16,678
Fiveways
The point I was making is that the SNP are currently on course to take anything between 28 - 35 seats from Labour in Scotland. These are seats that Labour strategists would have relied upon when calculating their expected total. They are now going to have to find another 30 or seats in England and Wales that they believe they can take form the Tories just to counter-act the ones they are going to lose in Scotland.
The paradox is that every seat the SNP win simply makes Labour's task of forming the next government harder. This is why Tories have been so fulsome in their praise of Nicola Sturgeon since Thursday's Leaders' debate.

The problem is that you said in post 2879 that the SNP's rise will lead to Cameron being returned to No 10. Now the Tories are going to get one seat, at best, in Scotland. Therefore Scotland is irrelevant as to whether the Tories are returned to power. What matters is what goes on in England. I do agree that the SNP will prevent a majority Labour government, but it's not clear who will be in a position to organise either a Coalition or, more likely, a minority government. At present, it's looking far more likely that it will be Labour that are in the position to make this decision.
The Tories and their cheerleaders in the press are, as ever, trying to make mischief.
 




Herr Tubthumper

Well-known member
NSC Patron
Jul 11, 2003
59,685
The Fatherland






Herr Tubthumper

Well-known member
NSC Patron
Jul 11, 2003
59,685
The Fatherland
We are biggest overseas aid contributors in the EU, Can you guess which countries pay the least without looking it up?

Greece? Spain? Slovakia?
 


The Birdman

New member
Nov 30, 2008
6,313
Haywards Heath
Labour could lose seats in Wales thanks to the Welsh lass standing up against Farage the other night. But let's hope you guys in Brighton vote for anything else than the greens they are further left than the SNP. We have better recycling in Tory run Mid Sussex than you have in Brighton and our council tax has been frozen again .
 




Herr Tubthumper

Well-known member
NSC Patron
Jul 11, 2003
59,685
The Fatherland
It's not mischief but the Tories and their Press poodles are shit scared now of a Milliband/Sturgeon government hence all the bullshit stories that are appearing, trouble is they can't fight on their record over the last 5 years so have to resort to lies and scaremongering

Very much this. I trust the UK to see through this bullshit though.
 


Machiavelli

Well-known member
Oct 11, 2013
16,678
Fiveways
Labour could lose seats in Wales thanks to the Welsh lass standing up against Farage the other night. But let's hope you guys in Brighton vote for anything else than the greens they are further left than the SNP. We have better recycling in Tory run Mid Sussex than you have in Brighton and our council tax has been frozen again .

I'm going to have to disappoint you, as I'll be voting Green in both national and local elections. Caroline Lucas will be returned in Pavilion in all likelihood, and let me predict that the Greens do a lot better in the council elections than many are predicting. But please explain what recycling has got to do with our local MP. Council tax freezes constitute a real terms reduction, which we've been subjected to for far too long, and results in poorer local services.
 


Horton's halftime iceberg

Blooming Marvellous
Jan 9, 2005
16,484
Brighton
Labour could lose seats in Wales thanks to the Welsh lass standing up against Farage the other night. But let's hope you guys in Brighton vote for anything else than the greens they are further left than the SNP. We have better recycling in Tory run Mid Sussex than you have in Brighton and our council tax has been frozen again .

Yes but we have a very good Green MP who stands up for her great values (who has nothing/v little to do with recycling quotas or council tax in our town) and you have a Tory MP always will have, and will never have a choice to change that
 




Pavilionaire

Well-known member
Jul 7, 2003
30,615
Labour could lose seats in Wales thanks to the Welsh lass standing up against Farage the other night.

If this was to be the case then the debates are counter-productive as people then start to vote on personality rather than policy.

Before Thursday the parties wanted to avoid talking about coalition options. Yet the leaders debate has now made it the main topic, and MIchael Gove's talking up of Sturgeon and the SNP on QT has muddied the waters even more.
 


Hatterlovesbrighton

something clever
Jul 28, 2003
4,543
Not Luton! Thank God
The problem is that you said in post 2879 that the SNP's rise will lead to Cameron being returned to No 10. Now the Tories are going to get one seat, at best, in Scotland. Therefore Scotland is irrelevant as to whether the Tories are returned to power. What matters is what goes on in England. I do agree that the SNP will prevent a majority Labour government, but it's not clear who will be in a position to organise either a Coalition or, more likely, a minority government. At present, it's looking far more likely that it will be Labour that are in the position to make this decision.
The Tories and their cheerleaders in the press are, as ever, trying to make mischief.

Not quite true. While you're right that the conservatives won't gain any MPs from
Labour losing to SNP it may well mean that they get more MPs than labour meaning they can say they "won" the election and so have the "moral" authority to have first go at forming a government.
 


8ace

Banned
Jul 21, 2003
23,811
Brighton
Yes but we have a very good Green MP who stands up for her great values (who has nothing/v little to do with recycling quotas or council tax in our town) and you have a Tory MP always will have, and will never have a choice to change that

It amazes my how many people on here seem take such an interest in our Green MP and the council, whereas I couldn't give a flying **** who the MP is in Worthing, Mid Sussex or Grimsby etc.
 


Machiavelli

Well-known member
Oct 11, 2013
16,678
Fiveways
Not quite true. While you're right that the conservatives won't gain any MPs from
Labour losing to SNP it may well mean that they get more MPs than labour meaning they can say they "won" the election and so have the "moral" authority to have first go at forming a government.

As the incumbent, the Tories had under the previous rules (and may still do) have first dib in the eventuality of a hung parliament. Their problem though is that the combined seats of Labour and the SNP looks likely to be sufficient to prevent them from getting any legislation through.
The Tories are the party of the establishment, and that grants them the belief that they have the 'moral' (although they just don't understand this word) authority to govern irrespective of what the electorate does.
 




Surf's Up

Well-known member
Jul 17, 2011
10,191
Here
I'm going to have to disappoint you, as I'll be voting Green in both national and local elections. Caroline Lucas will be returned in Pavilion in all likelihood, and let me predict that the Greens do a lot better in the council elections than many are predicting. But please explain what recycling has got to do with our local MP. Council tax freezes constitute a real terms reduction, which we've been subjected to for far too long, and results in poorer local services.

I have to admit I find myself more and more convinced by Lucas. As for the council, I will require a lot more persuading to vote Green.
 


Machiavelli

Well-known member
Oct 11, 2013
16,678
Fiveways
I have to admit I find myself more and more convinced by Lucas. As for the council, I will require a lot more persuading to vote Green.

The council haven't done themselves any favours with all their in-fighting. I'm not sure that they've got too many decisions wrong (I'm in favour of their transport changes, for instance), and they've had a tough time given:
-- none had any experience of running the council
-- they were a minority administration, and the party structure made it even more difficult for the councillors (and one or two of the councillors, e.g. Ben Duncan, behaved like an idiot, utterly oblivious to those he was supposed to represent)
-- they were working within the confines of the devolved axe
I suspect that they'll end up with about ten seats.
 


Albion and Premier League latest from Sky Sports


Top
Link Here